"I Contain Multitudes" by Ed Yong: Summary and Review


9 min read≈ 2,090 words5 questions · up to 5 points
What this is about
A squid that cannot finish building its own body without the right bacteria, and an insect bacterium that now helps to protect cities from dengue: Ed Yong's book is full of such partnerships. You learn the seven ideas behind the book, the terms Yong uses for them, and which of its medical hopes have come true since 2016. At the end you know whether to read the book or listen to it.
The book in three sentences· skip ahead
I Contain Multitudes argues that every animal, humans included, is a community of microbes as well as an individual. Yong shows how bacteria help build bodies, train immune systems, open new diets and spread new genes, and he explains disease as a partnership that has broken down rather than as an attack. The payoff is a new view of what an animal is, and a clear warning that changing our microbes on purpose is still hard.
I Contain Multitudes: The Microbes Within Us and a Grander View of Life
- Author
- Ed Yong
- Published
- 2016
- Publisher
- Vintage (paperback, 2017)
- Length
- 368 pages
- Audiobook
- 9h 52m, read by Charlie Anson
- Best for
- Curious readers who want to understand what microbes do for animals and people, told through field trips and real researchers rather than health advice.
Ed Yong’s first book argues that no animal is really one individual, because every animal lives, grows and dies together with microbes. When the book appeared in August 2016, the microbiome was one of the most fashionable subjects in biology, and newspapers linked gut bacteria to almost every illness.
Yong, a British science journalist then writing for The Atlantic, chose a wider and calmer approach. He wrote about squids, corals, insects and worms as well as people, and he asked what microbes mean for life as a whole, not only for our health. The book was shortlisted for the Wellcome Book Prize in 2017 and named one of the New York Times 100 Notable Books of 2016.
What kind of book this is
I Contain Multitudes is a work of science journalism, not a report of the author’s own research. Yong visited laboratories, zoos, coral reefs and insect collections and interviewed many of the researchers who built the field. The title borrows a line from Walt Whitman’s poem “Song of Myself”, and the book has a prologue and ten chapters. The early chapters say what microbes do for animals, the middle chapters show how these partnerships evolve, and the last chapters ask how people might change them on purpose.
This review takes the book’s seven main ideas in that order. If the word “microbiome” is new to you, What Is the Microbiome? explains the basics in five minutes.
Every animal is a community of species, “a multi-species collective”
The book’s central claim is that every animal is a community of many species living in one body. The prologue opens at San Diego Zoo, where the microbiologist Rob Knight swabs a pangolin called Baba to collect its bacteria. Yong’s point is that Baba carries his own population of microbes in his gut and on his skin, and so does every other animal in the zoo, and every visitor too.
Every one of us is a zoo in our own right—a colony enclosed within a single body.
Yong then uses the language of ecology for the body. The skin, the mouth and the gut each hold their own community, as a desert and a rainforest hold different species. Scientists can describe these communities with the same ideas that ecologists use for forests and reefs, such as diversity, food webs and invasive species. In chapter 2, “The People Who Thought to Look”, Yong tells how the Dutch lens maker Antonie van Leeuwenhoek first saw bacteria in the 1670s, and how microbes later became known mainly as germs. The rest of the book tries to correct that one-sided picture.
Microbes help build animal bodies (“Body Builders”)
Chapter 3, “Body Builders”, argues that many animals cannot develop normally without their microbes. The clearest example is the Hawaiian bobtail squid, which hunts in shallow water at night. A special organ on its underside holds the glowing bacterium Vibrio fischeri, and the light hides the squid’s shadow from predators below. A young squid catches these bacteria from the sea water, and the bacteria then send the signals that finish building the organ. Without them, the light organ never matures.
The same pattern appears in very different animals. Mice raised in sterile bubbles, with no microbes at all, have problems with their gut, bones, blood vessels and behaviour. In an interview with NPR in 2016, Yong described such a mouse as “a silhouette that hasn’t been filled in yet”. The chapter also covers the immune system, which in Yong’s account is not only an army that fights microbes but also a system that microbes help to build and calibrate. This is the book’s most surprising idea, because it means that an animal’s genome does not contain the full plan for its body.
No microbe is good or bad in every situation (“Terms and Conditions Apply”)
Chapter 4 argues that whether a microbe helps or harms depends on the situation, which Yong summarises with the title “Terms and Conditions Apply”. A bacterium that is useful in the gut can be deadly in the blood, and a partner can turn against its host when the host is weak. Yong’s favourite example is Wolbachia, a bacterium found in roughly four in ten species of insects and their relatives. In some species it kills males or turns them into females, while in others it is a useful partner.
there isn’t really any such thing as a good microbe or a bad microbe.
Because partners can turn harmful, hosts must keep them under control, and the chapter shows how they do it. Mucus keeps most gut bacteria away from the gut wall, and immune cells sample the microbes all the time. Human breast milk contains complex sugars that a baby cannot digest at all. They feed particular gut bacteria, such as Bifidobacterium infantis, so a mother helps to choose her baby’s first microbes.
Many diseases are disturbed ecosystems (“dysbiosis”)
Chapter 5, “In Sickness and in Health”, applies the ecological view to illness. Scientists use the word dysbiosis for a microbial community that has changed in a harmful way. Yong compares it with a coral reef that loses its fish through overfishing and becomes covered in algae. In a reef, no single invader causes the damage. The balance of the whole community shifts, and the new state can be hard to reverse.
He applies this view to obesity, inflammatory bowel disease and the loss of microbial diversity in people who live in cities and take many antibiotics. Here the book is careful. Yong describes the famous experiments in which germ-free mice that received microbes from obese donors gained more weight than mice that received microbes from lean ones. He also stresses a later study in which microbes from lean donors protected mice only when the mice ate a diet rich in plant fibre. The lesson he draws is that microbes influence health, but they offer no simple cure.
Partnerships evolve and open new ways of life
Chapters 6 and 7, “The Long Waltz” and “Mutually Assured Success”, follow these partnerships through evolutionary time. Yong shows how a free-living bacterium can become a permanent resident inside its host’s cells. One case is Sodalis, which lives inside tsetse flies, and a close relative of it that doctors found in an infected wound in a man, which suggests how such partners begin: as bacteria that can also cause infections. The mitochondria in our own cells, which supply most of their energy, also began as bacteria about two billion years ago, the story told in What Is Endosymbiotic Theory?.
Such partnerships let animals live in ways they could not manage alone. Sap-sucking insects such as aphids drink plant sap, which lacks several nutrients they need, and bacteria inside their cells make those nutrients. The deep-sea tubeworm Riftia has lost its mouth and gut, because bacteria in its body turn chemicals from hot springs on the sea floor into food. Yong also discusses the term holobiont, an animal together with all its microbes, and he reports that biologists still disagree about whether the holobiont should count as a unit of evolution.
Microbes share genes, so they adapt quickly (“Allegro in E Major”)
Chapter 8 explains why microbes can change much faster than animals. Bacteria pass genes to each other directly, even between different species, which is called horizontal gene transfer. That is how resistance to antibiotics spreads so fast in hospitals. Sometimes bacterial genes even move into animals. The coffee berry borer, a small beetle, uses a gene that came from bacteria to digest the sugars in coffee beans.
For the host, this means that its microbes give it access to new abilities much faster than its own slow evolution could. This chapter is shorter than the others, but it gives a real reason for the book’s main claim: an animal with microbes can draw on the genes of many species.
Changing our microbes on purpose is possible, but hard (“Microbes à la Carte”)
Chapters 9 and 10 ask how people can change microbial partnerships to their advantage. Yong is sceptical of most probiotics, the capsules and yogurts with live bacteria. He told NPR that the swallowed bacteria are like “a breeze that blows between two open windows”, because they pass through without settling. Faecal transplants, which move a whole community from a healthy donor into a patient, work much better for recurring infections with Clostridioides difficile.
The most ambitious project in the book uses Wolbachia against dengue fever. Australian researchers put the bacterium into the mosquito that spreads dengue, because mosquitoes that carry it transmit the virus poorly, and the bacterium then spreads through wild mosquito populations by itself. The final chapter, “Tomorrow the World”, widens the view to the microbes in homes and hospitals, and to plans for designing healthier indoor microbial communities.
How it differs from other books on microbes and evolution
The book is easiest to place next to three neighbours.
- Richard Dawkins’s The Selfish Gene (1976) looks at evolution from the point of view of the gene and explains cooperation as the interest of genes. Yong adds something Dawkins mostly leaves out, namely that most of the genes in and on an animal belong to other species, and that cooperation between these species shapes bodies. The two books work well together, as “The Selfish Gene” by Richard Dawkins: Summary and Review shows.
- Martin Blaser’s Missing Microbes (2014) is written by a doctor and makes one strong case: that overuse of antibiotics is destroying our inherited microbes and adding to modern illnesses. Yong covers similar ground but treats it as one open question among many and spends most of the book on other animals.
- Yong’s own An Immense World (2022) has the same structure, a tour of many animals and the scientists who study them, but it is about how animals sense the world. It is the better choice if you liked the style of this book and want a new subject.
What makes I Contain Multitudes different from all three is its range. It moves from squids to sponges, termites, hyenas and people, and it treats medicine as one part of biology, not as its main purpose.
Where it falls short
The book has two weaknesses. The first is that some of the medical hopes it reports have weakened since 2016. Several promising results came from mice, including work in which a gut bacterium reduced autism-like behaviour in mice. In people, a large study in 2021 found that differences in the gut bacteria of autistic children are mainly explained by their narrower diet. Yong is more careful than most writers on the subject, and he often warns that a finding is early. Still, a reader in 2016 could leave the book more hopeful about quick microbial cures than the evidence allowed.
The second weakness is structural. The book is built from vivid stories, and it moves on before the reader sees how the stories fit together, so the general argument is sometimes harder to follow than the examples. The idea of the holobiont shows this. Yong reports the debate fairly, but a reader who wants the strongest case against treating an animal and its microbes as one unit should read the 2015 paper by Nancy Moran and Daniel Sloan in the references.
Some of the book’s hopes have also come true. In a trial in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, published in 2021, neighbourhoods where Wolbachia mosquitoes were released had 77 percent fewer dengue cases. In 2023 the US Food and Drug Administration approved the first capsule of purified bacteria from donor stool to prevent C. difficile infections from returning. In 2016 Yong had told NPR that a leading candidate for such a pill had just failed a major trial.
Which edition and format to choose
The book reads well in any format. The text is carried by stories and scenes, so the unabridged audiobook, read by Charlie Anson and lasting just under ten hours, works well. The print and ebook editions have one advantage: many footnotes and endnotes with sources and side remarks, which are useful if you want to check a claim. The British paperback from Vintage and the American paperback from Ecco both have 368 pages; the British edition uses British spelling. If you read it today, keep the date in mind and treat the medical chapters as a picture of the field in 2016, not as current advice.
Quiz
5 questions · up to 5 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
What happens to a young Hawaiian bobtail squid if the light-making bacterium Vibrio fischeri never reaches it?
Show answer
Its light organ does not develop fully, because the bacteria send the signals that finish building it. Yong uses the squid to show his idea of microbes as 'body builders': the animal's own genes are not enough to finish this organ.
What does Yong mean when he says the partnership between animals and microbes comes with 'terms and conditions'?
Show answer
Whether a microbe helps or harms depends on where it lives and on the state of its host, so the host must keep it in check. Yong's point is that no microbe is always good or always bad. The same species can help in the gut and cause harm in the blood.
A gut community loses many species after repeated courses of antibiotics, and a harmful bacterium spreads. How would Yong describe this?
Show answer
As a disturbed ecosystem, like a damaged coral reef, where the balance between species has broken down. Yong treats many diseases as ecological problems: the whole community changes, and harmful species take the space that others have left.
Deep-sea tubeworms called Riftia have no mouth and no gut. According to the book, how do they live?
Show answer
Bacteria inside their bodies turn chemicals from hot springs on the sea floor into food for the worm. This is Yong's strongest example of 'mutually assured success': the partnership lets the worm live where no animal could live alone.
How does this review suggest reading the book today?
Show answer
As a view of what animals are, with its medical hopes checked against later studies. The review praises the biology and the new view of life, but notes that some health findings from mice did not hold up in people.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: What Is the Microbiome? →The takeaway
I Contain Multitudes by Ed Yong argues that every animal is a community of many species, because its body is built and run together with microbes. Its main ideas are that microbes help shape organs and immune systems, that no microbe is always good or always bad, that many diseases are disturbed ecosystems, and that partnerships with bacteria have opened new ways of life. Its weakness is that some medical hopes come from mouse studies whose results were not confirmed in people. Read it for the view of nature it gives you, and treat its health claims as questions.
Key quotes
“Even when we are alone, we are never alone.”
“When we eat, so do they. When we travel, they come along. When we die, they consume us.”
Should you read it?
Read it if
- You want to understand why scientists now see animals as communities of species, with examples from squids to termites to people.
- You enjoy science writing that visits laboratories and field sites and explains the research through the people who do it.
- You have heard many health claims about the microbiome and want a careful writer to show what lies behind them.
Skip it if
- You want practical advice on diet, probiotics or gut health; the book offers almost none.
- You want the latest research; the book reflects the state of the field in 2016, and some medical findings have changed since.
- You prefer one long argument to a tour of many examples; the book is built from stories more than from a single line of reasoning.
As an Amazon Associate, mentua.org earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and never shapes the verdict.
Ideas from this book
- microbiomeThe microbiome is the community of microorganisms that live in and on the human body, mainly bacteria but also fungi, viruses and other microbes, together with their genes. Most of them live in the large intestine. They digest fibre that we cannot digest, help train the immune system and make it hard for harmful bacteria to settle in the gut.
- endosymbiotic theoryEndosymbiotic theory says that mitochondria, which supply the energy of our cells, and the chloroplasts of plants were once free-living bacteria. Long ago they were taken into another cell, survived there and became permanent parts of it. They still have two membranes, their own ring of DNA and bacterial-type ribosomes, and their genes are closest to bacterial genes.
References
- I Contain Multitudes. Ed Yong
The author's page for the book, with its prizes and the YouTube series based on it.
- Eating Yogurt Is Not Enough: Rebalancing the Ecosystem of 'The Microbes Within Us'. Terry Gross with Ed Yong, NPR Fresh Air, 2016
A long interview in which Yong explains the book's main ideas in his own words, with a full transcript.
- The Hologenome Concept: Helpful or Hollow?. Nancy A. Moran and Daniel B. Sloan, PLOS Biology, 2015
Two leading symbiosis researchers explain why treating an animal and its microbes as one unit of evolution is often misleading.
- Efficacy of Wolbachia-Infected Mosquito Deployments for the Control of Dengue. Adi Utarini, Cameron P. Simmons and colleagues, New England Journal of Medicine, 2021
The trial in Yogyakarta, Indonesia, which tested the Wolbachia method that Yong describes and found 77 percent fewer dengue cases.





