What Is a Meme?


5 min read≈ 1,180 words3 questions · up to 3 points
What this is about
A letter that promised good luck to everyone who made 20 copies within 96 hours reached a family in Vermont in 1994, and its own text claimed it had been travelling since 1903. You learn the idea Richard Dawkins used to explain such letters, what makes some ideas better at spreading than others, and how today's internet memes relate to his word. You also learn why the science built on it ran out of results.
In a nutshell· skip ahead
A meme, in the sense Richard Dawkins gave the word in 1976, is a unit of culture, such as a tune, a phrase, a skill or an idea, that is copied from person to person by imitation. Like genes, memes vary and compete, so the ones that spread are those that are good at being copied, whether or not they are true or useful.
In 1994 a letter arrived at a house in Vermont. It promised good luck to anyone who made 20 copies and sent them on within 96 hours, and it told of people who lost a job, a wife or their life because they did not. The letter was signed “St Jude” and said that it had been travelling around the world since 1903. Nobody gained anything from it, so why had people kept copying it for so long?
What is a meme?
A meme, in the sense the biologist Richard Dawkins gave the word in 1976, is a unit of culture that is copied from one person to another by imitation. His examples were tunes, ideas, catchphrases, fashions and ways of making pots or building arches. Dawkins saw memes as replicators, things that make copies of themselves, like genes. Copies vary and some are copied more than others, so culture changes by a kind of natural selection, which favours what is good at being copied, not what is true or useful.
Just as genes propagate themselves in the gene pool by leaping from body to body via sperms or eggs, so memes propagate themselves in the meme pool by leaping from brain to brain via a process which, in the broad sense, can be called imitation.
Dawkins named three qualities that help a meme spread: fidelity (it is copied accurately), fecundity (it makes many copies) and longevity (each copy lasts). The St Jude letter has all three, and it also shows variation and selection at work.
- Fecundity. The letter asks every reader for 20 copies. Oliver Goodenough, whose wife had received the letter, wrote about it with Dawkins in the journal Nature. They calculated that if everyone obeyed, eight generations would put 20 to the power of 8, about 25.6 billion copies, into the post, or about four and a half letters for every person alive at the time.
- Fidelity. The letter is written, so each copy can repeat it almost word for word, including the instruction to copy it.
- Longevity. A spokesman for the US Postal Inspection Service told the two authors that the letter was older than the service’s own memory and kept coming back in outbreaks.
- Variation. Copies changed: an “ARP officer”, a British air-raid warden of the Second World War, became an “RAF officer” in other versions. In 2003 three researchers, Charles Bennett, Ming Li and Bin Ma, collected 33 chain letters from 1980 to 1995 and built a family tree for them with a method first made for genomes.
- Selection. Most people throw such letters away, which is why the world is not buried in them. The versions that survive are those whose promises and threats make a few readers obey, by using guilt, fear, greed and piety, as Goodenough and Dawkins put it.
How does an internet meme relate to Dawkins’ meme?
Today most people use “meme” for a picture or video that is shared online and changed by each user, such as a photo with ever new captions. The communication scholar Limor Shifman defined the internet meme in 2013 as a group of digital items that share content, form or attitude, are made with awareness of each other, and are copied and changed by many users online. She notes that Dawkins described one unit of culture, while an internet meme is the whole group of versions.
The second difference is how memes change. Dawkins’ meme changes mostly by accident, through copying errors, while internet memes are changed on purpose by their users. Dawkins made this point himself in a 2013 performance for the advertising agency Saatchi & Saatchi. The internet meme is therefore one narrow and very visible case of the older idea.
What the meme teaches you
The meme idea gives you a second question to ask about any message: apart from whether it is true, why is it good at being passed on?
- News and rumours. A message that ends with “Forward this to ten friends” uses the same trick as the St Jude letter. The request raises the number of copies and says nothing about whether the warning is true.
- Studies. A catchy but wrong explanation can outlive a correct one that is harder to remember, so when something sounds right, ask whether you know it is right or only remember it well.
- Your own habits. Many of your sayings, opinions and routines came from people around you. Asking where you picked something up is a first step to deciding whether you want to keep it.
Where does the meme idea break down?
The most common mistake is to read the meme as a thing with goals, but a meme does not want anything. “Selfish” describes only which variants become common, as it does for genes, and a “selfish” gene can even make an animal help its relatives, as Kin Selection and Hamilton’s Rule, Explained shows.
The deeper problem is that memetics, the planned science of memes, never produced firm results. The Journal of Memetics appeared from 1997 to 2005 and then closed for lack of good submissions. In its last issue Bruce Edmonds, who builds computer models of social processes, argued that memetics had added no power to explain or predict anything beyond what was already possible without the comparison with genes.
There are two main reasons for this failure. Nobody can say what counts as one meme: is it a tune, a single line of it, or a style of music? Copying is also far less exact than with genes. The French anthropologist Dan Sperber argued that people rebuild ideas in their own minds rather than copy them, so similar ideas recur because human minds tend to rebuild them in similar ways.
Research did not stop, however. Models of cultural evolution, which describe how fashions, words and techniques spread through a population, treat learning as error-prone and drawing on many sources, so they do not need exact copies.
Learn more
The word has a single, dated origin. Dawkins coined it in chapter 11 of The Selfish Gene in 1976, shortening the Greek mimeme, “something imitated”, so that it would sound like “gene”. In a 1999 foreword to Susan Blackmore’s book The Meme Machine, he said that his aim had been modest. He wanted to stop readers from thinking that the gene was the “be-all and end-all of evolution”, and to show that natural selection can work on any replicator. The philosopher Daniel Dennett and the psychologist Susan Blackmore developed the idea further, while the anthropologist Robert Boyd and the biologist Peter Richerson built their theory of cultural evolution in 1985 without relying on memes.
To see the meme in its original setting, read “The Selfish Gene” by Richard Dawkins: Summary and Review, which explains why this chapter is the book’s weakest part. For the mechanism the meme borrows, from variation to selection, read Natural Selection: How It Works and Why It Matters.
Quiz
3 questions · up to 3 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
According to Dawkins' idea of the meme, which ideas become common in a culture?
Show answer
Those that are good at getting themselves copied, whether or not they are true or helpful. A meme is selected for how well it is copied. Truth and usefulness can help it spread, but they are not required.
A message on a messaging app warns of a danger and ends with 'Forward this to ten friends now'. Seen as a meme, what does the last line do?
Show answer
It is an instruction that raises the number of copies, whether or not the warning is true. Like the St Jude letter's '20 copies within 96 hours', the line raises fecundity. It tells you nothing about whether the warning is accurate.
Which statement about memes matches the article?
Show answer
Memetics as a separate science stalled, but research on cultural evolution continues without relying on the meme. The Journal of Memetics closed in 2005 for lack of good submissions, while models of cultural evolution that do not need exact copying are still in use.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: "The Selfish Gene" by Richard Dawkins: Summary and Review →The takeaway
A meme, in Richard Dawkins' 1976 sense, is a piece of culture that people copy from one another. It spreads if it is copied accurately, makes many copies and lasts, whether or not it helps the people who carry it. The St Jude chain letter shows this: it asked each reader for 20 copies and survived for decades in slightly changed versions. Memetics did not become a working science, because a meme is hard to define and people rebuild ideas rather than copy them exactly, but it still helps to ask why a message spreads, separately from whether it is true.
References
- The 'St Jude' mind virus. Oliver Goodenough and Richard Dawkins, Nature 371, 23–24, 1994
A collection of eleven versions of the St Jude chain letter, together with the text of the short Nature letter in which Goodenough and Dawkins describe it as a virus of the mind.
- Evolution and Memes: The human brain as a selective imitation device. Susan Blackmore, Cybernetics and Systems 32 (1), 225–255, 2001
The strongest defender of memetics explains Dawkins' definition, the qualities fidelity, fecundity and longevity, and her own ideas about memes and language.
- The Meme as Meme. Abby Rabinowitz, Nautilus, 2013
A readable essay on how Dawkins' word became the internet meme, why he drew a line between the two, and why the Journal of Memetics folded.
- Cultural Evolution. Tim Lewens and Andrew Buskell, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023
A careful overview of the main objections to memes, including Dan Sperber's view that people rebuild ideas rather than copy them, and of the population models used today.
- A Meme is a Terrible Thing to Waste: An Interview with Limor Shifman (Part One). Henry Jenkins, Pop Junctions, 2014
The author of Memes in Digital Culture explains her definition of the internet meme and how it differs from Dawkins' single unit of culture.





