What Is Karma?


6 min read≈ 1,220 words3 questions · up to 3 points
What this is about
When a rude driver gets a flat tire a minute later, people call it karma. The traditions that gave us the word would mostly disagree. You learn what karma means in its oldest texts, why Buddhists and Jains argued over an insect crushed by accident, and why the idea becomes cruel when it is used to explain other people's suffering.
In a nutshell· skip ahead
Karma is the teaching, shared by Hinduism, Buddhism and Jainism, that every deliberate action leaves a trace in the person who does it and later ripens into a result, in this life or a future one. No judge hands out the results. The process works like a seed growing into a fruit, and it shapes above all who you become.
A driver cuts in front of you on the motorway, and two minutes later you pass him on the hard shoulder with a flat tire. Most people would smile and say “karma”. Yet the Hindu, Buddhist and Jain teachers who have used the word for more than 2,500 years would mostly not call the flat tire karma at all. So what did they mean?
What does karma actually mean?
Karma is Sanskrit for “action”. As a teaching, it says that every deliberate action leaves a trace in the person who does it, and that this trace later ripens into a result for that same person, in this life or in a future one. No judge decides the result. The traditions compare the process to a seed that grows into a fruit in its own time, for the one who planted it.
Karma comes together with rebirth, the belief that a person is born again after death, so that a result can ripen in a later life. In all three traditions the final aim is not to collect good karma but to get free of this cycle of rebirth.
The oldest clear statement of the idea is in the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, one of the earliest Hindu philosophical texts. A man asks the sage Yajnavalkya what is left of a person after death. Yajnavalkya asks for his hand and leads him out of the crowd, because the answer should not be discussed in public. The text then reports what the two agreed on: “one indeed becomes good through good work and evil through evil work.” The stress lies on what the action makes of the person, not on a reward from outside.
Does an accident count as karma?
The three traditions agree on this frame but disagree on what exactly counts as karma, and a real case from the Buddhist scriptures shows the difference. In Majjhima Nikaya 56, the Buddha debates with followers of Mahavira, the great Jain teacher of his time. He raises the case of a Jain monk who walks along a road and crushes small creatures that he did not see. The text is Buddhist, but its account of the Jain view matches what Jains teach.
The Buddhist answer is that intention, in Pali cetanā, is what makes an act karma. The monk did not want to kill, so this is not the karma of killing. In the debate the Buddha argues that the deed of the mind weighs more than the deed of the body.
Intention, I tell you, is kamma. Intending, one does kamma by way of body, speech, & intellect.
The Jain answer is that karma is a real substance. Jains describe it as very fine matter that every activity of body, speech and mind draws toward the soul. Passions such as anger and greed work like glue and make it stick. An unintended harm binds less karma than a deliberate one, but it still binds some, and in the debate the Jain side holds that the deed of the body weighs most. This is why Jain monks and nuns carry a small broom and sweep the ground before they sit down.
The Hindu answers vary between schools. Most theistic schools add God, who oversees the results and can soften or even cancel them. In the story of Ajamila, told in Who Are the Twelve Mahajanas?, a dying man’s many bad deeds do not decide his fate, because he calls out Narayana, a name of God.
So the same accident is almost nothing for a Buddhist, a real but smaller fault for a Jain, and for many Hindus a matter that God may judge with mercy. Western philosophers reached a similar distinction from another direction in What Is the Trolley Problem?, where a harm you intend weighs differently from one you only foresee.
What karma teaches you
The useful question that karma teaches is “What is this act turning me into?”, and you do not need to believe in rebirth to ask it.
- Habits. Each time you snap at a colleague or keep a promise, the next time becomes a little easier, so you become what you do, as the Upanishad says, even without any belief in future lives.
- Blame and responsibility. The old debate returns in modern law, where courts punish a deliberate killing more harshly than a careless one but still hold careless people responsible. When you judge a mistake, your own or a friend’s, ask both questions: what was intended, and how much care was taken?
- Your own reactions. By the Buddha’s definition, the pleased thought “he got what he deserved” is itself an intention, so it is karma for whoever thinks it. Like the Stoic idea in What Is the Dichotomy of Control?, this turns your attention back to your own choices.
Where does the idea of karma go wrong?
The popular version gets karma wrong in two ways. “Instant karma”, the title of a 1970 song by John Lennon, imagines a referee who punishes rude drivers within minutes. The traditions say almost the opposite: results can ripen now, later in life or in a future life, and the Buddha listed the exact working of karma among the four things that cannot be worked out by thinking. One flat tire tells you nothing about karma.
The second problem is the strongest objection to the idea itself: if every misfortune is the result of past actions, then every victim has earned their suffering.
Early texts do link karma to social rank: the Chandogya Upanishad says that people of good conduct are reborn into the higher classes and people of bad conduct as a dog, a pig or an outcaste. In 1999 the England football manager Glenn Hoddle lost his job after a newspaper reported him saying that disabled people were paying for deeds in an earlier life. He said he had been misinterpreted, but the anger showed how the idea sounds when applied to other people. Philosophers such as Whitley Kaufman add that nobody remembers the past lives that would explain their pain.
Here the early Buddhist texts make a surprising point against their popular reading. A wanderer named Sivaka asked whether everything a person feels comes from past deeds. The Buddha named eight causes of pain, such as disorders of the body, the change of seasons and attacks by others, and only the eighth was karma. Those who blame everything on past deeds, he said, are wrong. Read this way, karma is a teaching about your own actions, not a way to explain other people’s misfortune. The traditions have not always followed that reading, and that is the honest limit of the idea.
Learn more
Karma has no single founder. The idea grew among teachers in northern India before the Buddha’s time, and the Brihadaranyaka Upanishad preserves one of its first clear statements. The Buddha and Mahavira, two contemporaries, both took it over and changed it in opposite directions, one toward the mind and the other toward matter, and later Hindu schools added God.
For a Chinese view of good and bad luck with no law of cause and effect behind it, read What Is the Parable of the Chinese Farmer?.
Quiz
3 questions · up to 3 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
In the Buddhist text Anguttara Nikaya 6.63, what does the Buddha say karma is?
Show answer
Intention, which then acts through body, speech and mind The Buddha says that intention is karma. A physical deed without the intention behind it does not carry the same weight.
A cook lights a fire and, without noticing, kills insects hidden in the wood. Which tradition would say this still binds some karma, though less than a deliberate killing?
Show answer
Jainism, because any activity draws karmic matter to the soul Jains treat karma as matter that activity draws in. Unintended harm binds less than deliberate harm, but it still binds, which is why Jain monks sweep the ground in front of them.
A colleague who took credit for your work is fired a week later, and a friend says: "That's karma." Which reply fits the traditional teaching best?
Show answer
You cannot read karma from one event, and many misfortunes have other causes. The Buddha said that the exact working of karma cannot be worked out, and that past deeds are only one of eight causes of pain.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: Who Are the Twelve Mahajanas? →The takeaway
Karma, Sanskrit for "action", is the teaching that deliberate actions leave a trace in the person who acts and later ripen into results, in this life or a later one, without a judge. The Buddha said that intention is karma, while Jains treat karma as fine matter that even careless harm draws to the soul. The idea fails when it explains other people's suffering, and the Buddha himself denied that all pain comes from past deeds. Use it as a question about yourself: what is this act turning me into?
Key quotes
“Intention, I tell you, is kamma. Intending, one does kamma by way of body, speech, & intellect.”
References
- Nibbedhika Sutta: Penetrative (AN 6.63). Thanissaro Bhikkhu (translator), Access to Insight, 1997
The Buddha's definition of karma as intention, and his statement that its results come in this life, later in life or after that.
- With Upāli (MN 56). Bhikkhu Sujato (translator), SuttaCentral
The debate between the Buddha and the followers of the Jain teacher about whether the deed of the body or the deed of the mind weighs more, including the case of insects crushed by accident.
- Sivaka Sutta: To Sivaka (SN 36.21). Thanissaro Bhikkhu (translator), Access to Insight
The short text in which the Buddha lists eight causes of pain and calls it wrong to say that everything a person feels comes from past deeds.
- Karma. Jasmine Kelly, JAINPEDIA
A clear introduction to the Jain view of karma as fine matter, how passions bind it, its eight main types and how it is removed.
- The Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, III.ii: Yajnavalkya and Artabhaga. Swami Madhavananda (translator), Wisdom Library, 1950
The oldest clear statement of the idea, with Shankara's commentary: two men leave a crowd to discuss what happens after death and agree that it is action.





