Skip to content
mentua.org

"Guns, Germs, and Steel" by Jared Diamond: Summary and Review

Line drawing of two crossing axes around a filled seed: along the solid horizontal axis with arrows at both ends, four seedlings sprout at even steps, while the dotted vertical axis carries only two faint dotted seedsLine drawing of two crossing axes around a filled seed: along the solid horizontal axis with arrows at both ends, four seedlings sprout at even steps, while the dotted vertical axis carries only two faint dotted seeds

9 min read≈ 2,060 words5 questions · up to 5 points

What this is about

In 1972 a politician in New Guinea asked an American biologist a simple question about rich and poor peoples, and the answer became a book of almost 500 pages. You learn the main steps of Jared Diamond's argument and how it compares with Sapiens and Why Nations Fail. You also learn what historians and anthropologists reject in it, and what newer research about early farming has changed.

The book in three sentences· skip ahead

Diamond argues that Europeans and Asians conquered other continents because of their environments, not because of any biological advantage. Eurasia had more wild plants and animals that could be domesticated, and its east-west shape let crops and ideas spread quickly. Farming then produced dense populations, which brought epidemic diseases, writing, technology, states and armies, the guns, germs and steel of the title.

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies

Author
Jared Diamond
Published
1997
Publisher
W. W. Norton, 20th anniversary edition, 2017
Length
494 pages
Audiobook
16h 20m, read by Doug Ordunio
Best for
Readers who want one clear argument about why some societies conquered others, and who are ready to test it against its critics.

Why did Spaniards conquer the Inca, and not the Inca Spain? Jared Diamond, an American biologist at UCLA who had studied the birds of New Guinea for many years, answered this kind of question with plants, animals and the shape of continents. Guns, Germs, and Steel (1997) won the Pulitzer Prize for general nonfiction in 1998 and became one of the most widely read history books of its time. It mattered because it gave a non-racist answer to a question that racist theories had long claimed for themselves. This review explains the book’s main steps, compares it with similar books, and says where historians, anthropologists and newer research disagree.

Yali’s question asks why wealth and power are so unequal

The book starts from a question that Yali, a local politician, asked Diamond on a beach in New Guinea in July 1972. “Cargo” was the local word for the goods that Europeans had brought, such as steel axes, cloth and medicine.

Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo and brought it to New Guinea, but we black people had little cargo of our own?

Yali, as reported by Jared Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel, Prologue

Diamond widens the question to the whole world: why did peoples from Eurasia conquer the Americas, Australia and most of Africa, and not the other way round? He first rejects the old answer that some peoples are biologically smarter. He argues that there is no evidence for it, and he even suggests that the New Guineans he knows are on average more alert and more intelligent than the average European or American. His alternative is the thesis of the book, which he sums up in one sentence in the prologue: history went differently for different peoples because their environments differed, not because the peoples did.

Steel, horses and germs were only the “proximate causes”

Diamond’s method depends on a distinction between proximate causes, the immediate reasons why one side won, and ultimate causes, the deeper reasons why that side had those advantages in the first place. His key example is Cajamarca, a town in the Andes of Peru, where in November 1532 Francisco Pizarro and 168 Spanish soldiers captured the Inca emperor Atahuallpa, who was surrounded by an army of tens of thousands.

The proximate causes are easy to list. The Spaniards had steel swords and armour, horses, and a few guns. They also had writing, which gave them reports about earlier conquests, while Atahuallpa knew almost nothing about them. A smallpox epidemic, carried to the Americas by earlier Europeans, had already reached the Inca empire before Pizarro arrived. Diamond then asks the question that the rest of the book answers: why did the Spaniards, and not the Inca, have steel, horses, ships, writing and deadly germs?

Farming gave some peoples a head start of thousands of years

Diamond’s first ultimate cause is food production, his term for growing crops and keeping animals instead of hunting and gathering. Farming produced far more calories per hectare, so the same land fed many more people. It also produced stored surpluses, which could feed people who did not grow food themselves, such as chiefs, priests, soldiers and craftsmen.

So the region where farming started first gained thousands of years of growth in numbers and in specialists. Diamond counts at most nine homelands where food production arose independently, among them China, Mesoamerica and the Andes. The first was the Fertile Crescent, the arc of land from the eastern Mediterranean to Iran.

How that shift began, and why it took so long, is the subject of What Was the Neolithic Revolution?. Ten years before the book, Diamond had called farming the worst mistake in human history, because early farmers were often less healthy than foragers. Guns, Germs, and Steel does not contradict that essay: farming could make each person’s life harder and still make a society larger and stronger.

Only a few wild species could become crops and livestock

Why did farming start early in some places and late or never in others? Diamond’s answer is that the useful wild species were unevenly spread. The Fertile Crescent had wild wheats, barley and peas, which were easy to grow, store and domesticate, as well as the wild ancestors of sheep, goats, cattle and pigs. Its climate, with mild wet winters and long dry summers, favoured annual plants with large seeds.

Animals show the same pattern. Diamond counts 148 wild species of large land mammals, weighing 45 kilograms or more, that could have been candidates, but only 14 of them were ever domesticated, and 13 of those 14 were Eurasian. He explains this with the Anna Karenina principle, named after the first sentence of Tolstoy’s novel about happy and unhappy families. A species can only be domesticated if it passes every one of several tests. It must eat food that people can provide, grow fast, breed in captivity, have a calm temper, not panic in enclosures, and live in herds with a clear hierarchy. What Is the Anna Karenina Principle? walks through these tests and shows where else the same logic applies.

Zebras and bears failed at least one test, so Africa and North America had almost nothing to domesticate except a few smaller species.

Crops and ideas spread faster along east-west axes

Diamond’s most original idea concerns the shape of the continents. Eurasia stretches mainly from east to west, while the Americas and Africa stretch mainly from north to south. In his 2002 summary of the book in the journal Nature, he put the claim this way:

Expansions of crops, livestock, and even people and technologies tended to occur more rapidly along east–west axes than along north–south axes

Jared Diamond, “Evolution, consequences and future of plant and animal domestication”, Nature, 2002

The reason is that places at the same latitude share day lengths and seasons and often a similar climate, so a crop that grows in one place usually grows in the other. Wheat and horses from western Asia reached Europe and China, while corn from Mexico spread only slowly to the north and south, because it had to adapt to new day lengths and seasons. The same axes slowed the spread of animals, tools and writing systems.

Most epidemics were a “lethal gift of livestock”

Diamond’s chapter on disease explains the “germs” of the title. Many deadly crowd diseases, such as measles, tuberculosis and influenza, began as diseases of domestic animals and later jumped to humans. Such diseases also need large, dense populations to keep circulating, and only farming produced those.

Eurasians lived with cattle, pigs and sheep for thousands of years and, over generations, built up some resistance. The peoples of the Americas had few domestic animals, so they had few crowd diseases of their own and no resistance to those of Eurasia. Diamond argues that these diseases became the most important weapon of the Europeans who conquered the Americas, often spreading ahead of the conquerors themselves. This part of the book has held up well.

Dense farming societies produced writing, technology and states

The third part of the book follows the chain from food to power. Writing, Diamond argues, was invented independently only a few times, in places with dense farming societies that needed records, and elsewhere it spread by borrowing. Technology grows in the same way: large, connected populations produce more inventors and copy more inventions from their neighbours.

Political organization follows population too. Diamond describes a sequence from bands to tribes, chiefdoms and states. He calls the larger forms a kleptocracy, his word for a system in which rulers take wealth from the people and give part of it back to keep them loyal. States could raise armies, build fleets and fund conquest, which closes the circle back to Cajamarca.

The book tests its theory on every continent

The fourth part runs through Australia and New Guinea, China, the Pacific islands, the Americas and Africa, and asks whether the theory explains each history. These chapters carry much of the evidence, from linguistics to archaeology, but they also repeat the argument many times.

In the epilogue Diamond turns to a harder question: why did Europe, and not China, conquer the world, although China had invented paper, printing and gunpowder? His answer is again geography. China’s rivers and coasts made it easy to unify, so a single court decision in the 15th century could end its great sea voyages. Europe’s mountains, peninsulas and islands kept it divided into competing states, and that competition pushed rulers to fund explorers and new technology. Diamond admits that a full answer would need another book.

How it differs from Sapiens and Why Nations Fail

Three neighbors show what is special about the book.

  • Yuval Noah Harari’s Sapiens covers the same deep history but asks a different question: why one species came to rule the planet. Harari’s answer is about beliefs and shared stories, Diamond’s is about environments. Diamond builds his argument more carefully from evidence, while Harari writes more boldly, as explained in “Sapiens” by Yuval Noah Harari: Summary and Review.
  • Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson’s Why Nations Fail (2012) attacks the geography explanation directly. Its authors accept that geography may explain some early inequalities but argue that today’s gap between rich and poor countries comes from political and economic institutions.
  • David Graeber and David Wengrow’s The Dawn of Everything (2021) rejects the idea of one fixed path from bands to states. It stresses that early societies chose very different ways to live, which is the room for choice that Diamond’s chain of causes leaves out.

What Guns, Germs, and Steel adds is a method. Diamond treats history as a field that can compare cases like a natural science, and he connects botany, zoology, medicine and linguistics into one explanation that a general reader can follow.

Where it falls short: too much geography, too little choice

The first problem is determinism, the view that the environment decides the outcome. William McNeill, a leading world historian, praised the chapters on farming in the New York Review of Books but argued that ideas, beliefs and deliberate choices also shape history.

I do not accept Diamond’s dismissive appraisal of “cultural idiosyncrasies unrelated to environment.”

William H. McNeill, “History Upside Down”, The New York Review of Books, 1997

The geographer James Blaut went further in 1999. He argued that Diamond uses evidence selectively, for example when he invokes diffusion only where it helps his case, and that the book repeats an old Eurocentric story in which history moves from the Fertile Crescent to Europe. The anthropologists Frederick Errington and Deborah Gewertz, who worked in Papua New Guinea, argued that Diamond also misread Yali: Yali cared less about the goods themselves than about the respect and social relations that came with them.

The second problem is that later research changed the picture of early farming. Diamond counted at most nine homelands, but a 2014 review by 25 specialists counts at least 11 independent centres of domestication. It describes a slow process over thousands of years in many regions, including New Guinea, Africa and India. Diamond himself noted in 2002 that cattle were domesticated separately in the Fertile Crescent and in the Indian subcontinent. The core claim, that a few regions had a head start, still stands, but the map is more crowded and less tidy than in the book.

The third problem is timing. The historian Kenneth Pomeranz argued in The Great Divergence (2000) that the richest parts of China and Europe stayed similar until about 1800, and that coal and colonies then made the difference. If that is right, ancient geography cannot explain the modern gap on its own. Some parts of the theory have found support, however: a 2012 study in PNAS found that languages persist more in countries that stretch from north to south, as the axis argument predicts.

Which format to choose

The print or ebook edition is the better choice, because the argument depends on maps and tables, such as the map of the homelands of food production and the table of domesticated mammals. The unabridged audiobook, read by Doug Ordunio, runs for more than 16 hours and works well for the story chapters, but the comparisons between continents are hard to follow without the maps. The book is long, so a good plan is to read the prologue, the chapters on Cajamarca, domestication, axes and germs, and the epilogue first, and to choose among the continent chapters afterwards.

Quiz

5 questions · up to 5 points

Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.

  1. In Diamond's terms, why are steel swords and horses at Cajamarca only 'proximate causes' of the Spanish victory?
    Show answer

    They explain the battle, but not why Spaniards had them and the Inca did not, which needs deeper causes. Diamond calls the immediate advantages proximate causes. His book looks for the ultimate causes behind them, which he finds in food production and geography.

  2. What does Diamond's 'Anna Karenina principle' say about domesticating large animals?
    Show answer

    A species can be domesticated only if it passes every one of several tests, so failing any single one rules it out. Diet, growth rate, breeding in captivity, temper, panic and social structure all have to fit. That is why only 14 of 148 large wild mammals were ever domesticated.

  3. A new crop variety grows well at the latitude of Spain. Following Diamond's argument, where would it most likely spread fastest?
    Show answer

    East and west, to places at the same latitude with similar day lengths, seasons and climate. Diamond argues that crops spread faster along east-west axes, because places at the same latitude share day length, seasons and often climate.

  4. Why, according to Diamond, did Eurasian germs kill so many Native Americans, while American germs did little harm to Europeans?
    Show answer

    Most epidemic diseases came from Eurasian livestock, and Eurasians had lived with them long enough to build up resistance. Diamond calls these diseases the lethal gift of livestock. Thirteen of the 14 large domestic mammals were Eurasian, so crowd diseases were concentrated there.

  5. How does this review suggest you read Guns, Germs, and Steel today?
    Show answer

    As a strong argument about deep causes whose details and determinism you check against later research and criticism. The review praises the method of asking deep causes but notes that historians, anthropologists and newer research about early farming have corrected several claims.

The takeaway

Guns, Germs, and Steel argues that differences in environment, not in people, explain why Eurasian societies conquered most of the world. Eurasia had more domesticable plants and animals and an east-west shape along which crops spread easily, so farming came early and brought dense populations, epidemics, writing, technology and states. Critics say the book neglects culture, choices and institutions, and newer research finds more centres of early farming and a slower process. Read it for its method of asking deep causes, and test its answers against later work.

Key quotes

“History followed different courses for different peoples because of differences among peoples' environments, not because of biological differences among peoples themselves.”
Jared Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel, Prologue

Should you read it?

Read it if

  • You want to understand how farming, domestic animals and geography shaped the last 13,000 years of history.
  • You like books that answer a big question step by step with evidence from many fields, from botany to linguistics.
  • You have read Sapiens and want an older, more evidence-based argument about the same deep history.

Skip it if

  • You want the current state of research on early farming; parts of the book are now out of date.
  • You are mainly interested in why some countries are rich today; books on institutions and the modern economy fit better.
  • You dislike long books that return to the same argument on every continent.

As an Amazon Associate, mentua.org earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and never shapes the verdict.

Ideas from this book

References

  1. Guns, Germs, and Steel (20th anniversary edition). Jared Diamond, W. W. Norton, 2017

    The publisher's page for the edition this review describes, with the Pulitzer Prize of 1998.

  2. Evolution, consequences and future of plant and animal domestication. Jared Diamond, Nature, 2002

    Diamond's own short scientific summary of the book's argument about domestication, axes and disease.

  3. History Upside Down. William H. McNeill, The New York Review of Books, 1997

    A leading world historian praises the book's account of farming and rejects its neglect of culture.

  4. Environmentalism and Eurocentrism. James M. Blaut, Geographical Review, 1999

    A geographer's critique of environmental determinism and of the book's picture of Europe.

  5. Current perspectives and the future of domestication studies. Greger Larson, Dolores Piperno, Robin Allaby and others, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2014

    A review by 25 specialists that counts at least 11 independent centres of domestication.

guns-germs-and-steeljared-diamondbook-reviewsummarybig-historyworld-historygeographyenvironmental-determinismdomesticationagricultureneolithic-revolutionfertile-crescentcontinental-axesepidemicssmallpoxyalis-questionpulitzer-prize