What Is the Anna Karenina Principle?


5 min read≈ 1,180 words3 questions · up to 3 points
What this is about
People have tried for centuries to ride and herd zebras, which look almost like horses, and they have always given up. You learn the principle Jared Diamond used to explain why so few wild animals ever became livestock, the arithmetic behind it, and how biologists now use the same idea to study sick and healthy bodies.
In a nutshell· skip ahead
The Anna Karenina principle says that success often needs many conditions to hold at the same time, while failure needs only one of them to go wrong. So successes look alike, while failures differ. Jared Diamond named it in 1997 after the first line of Tolstoy's novel and used it to explain why so few wild animals were domesticated.
Zebras live in the same grasslands as wild cattle, eat grass as horses do and look almost exactly like a striped horse. According to Jared Diamond, African herders tried to tame them for thousands of years, and European horse breeders who settled in South Africa from the 1600s tried for several centuries more, but in the end everyone gave up. Why could people turn the wild horse into a farm animal but not its close relative?
What does the Anna Karenina principle say?
The Anna Karenina principle says that success often needs many conditions to hold at the same time, while failure needs only one of them to go wrong. Diamond, an American geographer and biologist, gave it this name in Guns, Germs, and Steel (1997), after the first sentence of Leo Tolstoy’s novel Anna Karenina:
Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.
Diamond read the sentence as a piece of logic. A marriage is happy only if many things work at the same time, for example attraction, money and agreement about children. Because each family can fail at a different point, the unhappy families all look different, while the happy ones resemble each other, since they all passed the same tests. In logic, these tests are necessary conditions: things that must be true for the result to happen, although none of them is enough on its own.
Why were only 14 of 148 large mammals domesticated?
Diamond counted 148 wild species of large land mammals, plant eaters or omnivores of 45 kilograms or more, that could in principle have become livestock. Only 14 of them were ever domesticated, which means that people bred them over many generations until they depended on human care, among them the sheep, goat, cow, pig, horse, camel and llama. To join this list, a species had to pass six tests, and Diamond names animals that failed each one:
- Diet: it must eat food that people can supply cheaply, which rules out anteaters.
- Growth: it must grow up fast, which elephants and gorillas do not.
- Breeding in captivity: it must mate in an enclosure, which cheetahs and pandas rarely do.
- Temper: it must be safe to handle, unlike grizzly bears and rhinoceroses.
- Panic: it must stay calm behind a fence, which gazelles and most deer do not, with the reindeer as the exception.
- Social structure: it must live in herds that follow a leader, so that people can take the leader’s place, which many antelopes do not.
The zebra fails at temper and at handling. Diamond reports that zebras bite and do not let go, and that they injure more zoo-keepers each year than tigers do. They also see a rope coming and turn their head away, so even rodeo cowboys cannot catch them with a lasso. Many species, Diamond writes, passed five of the six tests and still remained wild, because one failed test was enough to stop them.
Simple arithmetic shows why so few succeed. Imagine that each test is passed by 70 percent of species and that the tests are independent of each other. Then the chance of passing all six is 0.7 multiplied by itself six times, about 12 percent, close to Diamond’s 14 out of 148, or 9.5 percent. Diamond did not make this calculation, and the tests are surely not independent, but it shows how a list of fairly easy tests becomes hard to pass as a whole.
The principle also explains the map. In Diamond’s count, about 18 percent of the large mammal species of Eurasia passed every test, but none of the 51 species of Africa south of the Sahara did. That difference gave Eurasian farmers horses, oxen and the diseases of livestock.
What the Anna Karenina principle teaches you
When a result depends on many conditions, ask which single one could stop it, because that one sets the limit. The principle also warns you not to look for one shared cause behind many failures.
- Planning. A grant application, a move abroad or a product launch usually needs every part to work, so extra effort on the best part helps little while one required document is still missing.
- Reading about failure. If you study why several companies, teams or relationships failed, expect a different reason in each case, and look for a shared pattern among the successful ones instead.
- Health. In 2017 the microbiologists Jesse Zaneveld, Ryan McMinds and Rebecca Vega Thurber applied the principle to the microbiome, the community of microbes that lives in and on an animal. They collected reports that healthy hosts have fairly similar communities while stressed hosts vary much more, from corals in unusually warm water to the lungs of smokers and people with HIV. Biologists had often treated this variation as noise, and the authors argued that it is a real pattern. The Idea on the microbiome explains what these communities do.
Where does the principle break down?
The principle has two limits. The first is that it holds only where every condition is required. Where a strength in one place can make up for a weakness in another, success can take many forms, and happy families do differ in many ways. A common misreading is therefore that all successful cases are identical, when they share only the required conditions and can differ in everything else.
The second limit is hindsight. If you first see which species became livestock and then list what they have in common, you will always find a neat list, because you are looking only at the survivors. Diamond answered that each of the six traits can be checked in a living animal without knowing whether it was ever domesticated. The objection keeps some force, because people’s choices also mattered, and domestication was a slow process over thousands of years rather than an exam with a fixed list of questions.
In biology, Zaneveld and his colleagues present the principle as one pattern among several, not as a rule that every stress follows, and they ask for careful tests with repeated measurements over time.
Learn more
The name is Diamond’s, but the idea is much older. More than 2,300 years ago Aristotle wrote in his Nicomachean Ethics that there are many ways to miss a target and only one way to hit it, and Tolstoy opened his novel with a similar thought in 1878. Diamond named the logic in 1997 in chapter 9 of Guns, Germs, and Steel and defended it in 2002 in a review in the journal Nature. Since 2017, microbiologists have used his name for patterns in their own data.
To see the principle inside Diamond’s whole argument, read “Guns, Germs, and Steel” by Jared Diamond: Summary and Review, which also explains what historians criticize in the book. To see how domestication itself worked, read What Was the Neolithic Revolution?, which follows wild wheat as it became a crop.
Quiz
3 questions · up to 3 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
What does the Anna Karenina principle say about success and failure?
Show answer
Success needs every one of several conditions, while a single failed condition is enough to fail, so failures differ from each other. This is the logic Diamond took from Tolstoy's first line. Successes share all the conditions, while each failure can break a different one.
A new phone app needs a working server, an approved payment system, a clear name and a store listing before launch. Which question follows from the Anna Karenina principle?
Show answer
Which of these four things is most likely to fail, since any one of them can stop the launch? When every condition is required, the launch is only as safe as its weakest part, so that part deserves the most attention.
According to Diamond, why were zebras never domesticated, although people in southern Africa tried for centuries?
Show answer
Zebras failed some of the required tests, because they bite and hold on and are very hard to catch with a rope. Diamond names their vicious temper and their wide field of vision. One failed test is enough to stop domestication.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: "Guns, Germs, and Steel" by Jared Diamond: Summary and Review →The takeaway
The Anna Karenina principle says that when success needs every one of several conditions, a single failed condition is enough to fail, so successes resemble each other and failures differ. Jared Diamond used it to explain why only 14 of 148 large wild mammals were domesticated: each failure broke a different rule. The principle holds only where conditions cannot make up for each other, and it is easy to apply too neatly in hindsight. Use it to find the one condition that could make a plan fail.
Key quotes
“For men are good in but one way, but bad in many.”
References
- Evolution, consequences and future of plant and animal domestication. Jared Diamond, Nature 418, 700–707, 2002
Diamond's own short review: the 148 candidate species and the 14 domesticated ones, the six obstacles with examples, the zebra story and his answer to the charge of circular reasoning.
- Stress and stability: applying the Anna Karenina principle to animal microbiomes. Jesse R. Zaneveld, Ryan McMinds and Rebecca Vega Thurber, Nature Microbiology 2, 17121, 2017
The paper that carried the principle into biology: stressed hosts have more varied microbial communities than healthy ones, with examples from corals to human lungs.
- Anna Karenina, translated by Constance Garnett. Leo Tolstoy, Standard Ebooks, 1901
A free, carefully edited edition of the classic English translation, which opens with the sentence about happy and unhappy families.
- Nicomachean Ethics, Book II, translated by W. D. Ross. Aristotle, The Internet Classics Archive, MIT, 1925
Section 6 contains a much older version of the same idea: there are many ways to miss a target and only one way to hit it.





