Skip to content
mentua.org

What Is Hawking Radiation?

Line drawing of a filled black hole inside a dotted ring that marks its former size, with wavy lines of radiation leaving it in four directionsLine drawing of a filled black hole inside a dotted ring that marks its former size, with wavy lines of radiation leaving it in four directions

5 min read≈ 1,210 words3 questions · up to 3 points

What this is about

Nothing can escape from a black hole, yet in 1974 Stephen Hawking calculated that black holes are not completely black. You learn what a black hole gives off, why one as heavy as the Sun is colder than the faint glow that fills the universe, and where the popular picture of particle pairs goes wrong. You also learn why the effect has been seen only in laboratory models so far.

In a nutshell· skip ahead

Hawking radiation is the faint heat that a black hole should give off because of quantum effects near its edge, the event horizon. Stephen Hawking calculated in 1974 that every black hole glows like a hot body, and the smaller it is, the hotter. The energy comes from the black hole's mass, so over immense times it shrinks and disappears.

A black hole is defined as a region from which nothing can escape, not even light. In 1974 Stephen Hawking, a physicist in Cambridge, published a calculation which said that black holes are not completely black after all: each one should glow faintly, lose mass and, given enough time, disappear. How can something that lets nothing out still give off heat?

How can a black hole give off heat?

Hawking radiation is the faint heat that every black hole should give off because of quantum effects near its event horizon, the boundary beyond which nothing can return. Hawking found that a black hole radiates like a hot body with a definite temperature, and that this temperature falls as the black hole’s mass rises. The energy of the radiation comes from the black hole’s own mass, so the black hole slowly shrinks. A black hole with the mass of the Sun shows the numbers.

  1. Its size. Squeezed into a black hole, the Sun’s mass would have an event horizon with a radius of about 3 kilometres.
  2. Its temperature. Hawking’s formula gives about 60 billionths of a degree above absolute zero (6 × 10⁻⁸ kelvin).
  3. Its surroundings. Space is filled with the cosmic microwave background, the cooled light of the early universe, at about 2.7 kelvin. That is roughly 44 million times warmer than our black hole.
  4. The balance. A cold body in warmer surroundings takes in more heat than it gives off, so this black hole grows today instead of shrinking.
  5. The far future. Only when the universe has cooled below the black hole’s temperature does it start to lose mass. Left alone, it would need about 10⁶⁷ years to evaporate, while the universe is 13.8 billion years old.

Halve the mass and the temperature doubles, so a shrinking black hole gets hotter, radiates faster and shrinks faster still. Hawking calculated that any black hole formed in the early universe with less than about 10¹⁵ grams, about a billion tonnes or less than a cubic kilometre of rock, would have evaporated by now in a final burst of radiation.

Is it really pairs of particles at the edge?

The popular explanation, which Hawking used himself, says that empty space is full of pairs of short-lived “virtual” particles that appear and vanish again. Near the horizon, one member of a pair can fall in while the other escapes, and the escaping particle looks like radiation from the black hole. Because the falling partner carries negative energy, the black hole loses mass.

The picture rightly says the effect is quantum and happens near the horizon, but it fails in two ways. The first is that Hawking did not derive anything from it. His calculation compares empty space before a star collapses with what a distant detector measures long afterwards. It finds that the strong stretching of space-time near the horizon turns the one into a steady glow of heat. Hawking warned against reading the pair story literally in the same paper.

It should be emphasized that these pictures of the mechanism responsible for the thermal emission and area decrease are heuristic only and should not be taken too literally.

Stephen Hawking, “Particle Creation by Black Holes”, Communications in Mathematical Physics (1975), p. 202

The second failure is size. The pair picture suggests tiny particles splitting right at the boundary, but the typical wavelength of the radiation from our solar-mass black hole is tens of kilometres, much larger than its 3-kilometre horizon. In 2016 the physicist Steven Giddings argued that the radiation comes from a “quantum atmosphere” about as large as the black hole itself, not from a thin layer at its edge.

What Hawking radiation teaches you

When two well-tested theories meet in one place, their combination can force a result that neither suggests alone, and often only a calculation, not a picture, can reach it. Hawking combined general relativity, Einstein’s theory of gravity, with quantum theory. The result was that black holes have a temperature and an entropy, a measure of how many inner states they can have, which What Is Entropy? explains for ordinary gases.

  • Reading science news. Headlines about “Hawking radiation seen in the lab” refer to models made of fluids or light, so ask what was measured, and on which object, before you believe them.
  • Learning any subject. Many fields teach with pictures that are useful but wrong in detail, such as electrons circling the nucleus like planets. Use the picture to start, and learn where it stops working.
  • Research. Since the physicist Bill Unruh proposed in 1981 that sound in a fast-flowing fluid behaves like light near a black hole, physicists have built such “analogue black holes” to test Hawking’s mathematics.

Has anyone ever seen Hawking radiation?

No one has detected Hawking radiation from a real black hole, and for the black holes we know of, no one expects to. The glow from a solar-mass black hole is far fainter than the microwave background around it. The only hope is small black holes from the early universe that would be ending their lives today, but a search through 959 days of data from the HAWC gamma-ray observatory, published in 2020, found no such final bursts.

The strongest evidence comes from the laboratory. In 2016 Jeff Steinhauer at the Technion in Haifa cooled rubidium atoms to almost absolute zero and made them flow faster than sound moves through them. Sound could not travel back upstream, much as light cannot climb out of a black hole, and he found linked pairs of sound waves on both sides of this “sonic horizon”. In 2019 his group reported that this sound had the spread of wavelengths typical of heat radiation, at the temperature Hawking’s formula predicts for the model. These experiments show that the mathematics works in a real system, but not that gravity behaves the same way, so for actual black holes the effect is still a prediction.

The prediction also leads to the most famous open problem about black holes. If a black hole evaporates into pure heat, the information about what fell into it seems to be lost, which quantum theory does not allow. Hawking first argued that the information is destroyed and changed his mind in 2004, and physicists still disagree about whether and how it gets out.

Learn more

Hawking radiation has a clear originator. In the early 1970s Jacob Bekenstein at Princeton proposed that a black hole has entropy in proportion to the area of its horizon, an idea Hawking at first rejected. In Moscow, Yakov Zeldovich and Alexei Starobinsky told him that spinning black holes should emit particles. Hawking then did the calculation himself in late 1973, published the result in Nature on 1 March 1974 and gave the full derivation in 1975.

Hawking tells the story of his discovery himself in the chapter “Black Holes Ain’t So Black” of his bestseller, which “A Brief History of Time” by Stephen Hawking: Summary and Review summarizes and judges. For the cold glow of the early universe that fills the whole sky, read Why Is the Night Sky Dark? Olbers’ Paradox, Explained.

Quiz

3 questions · up to 3 points

Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.

  1. Why is a black hole with the mass of the Sun not shrinking today, although it gives off Hawking radiation?
    Show answer

    It is far colder than the cosmic microwave background, so it absorbs more energy than it radiates. Its temperature is about 60 billionths of a degree, while the background glow of the universe is about 2.7 degrees above absolute zero.

  2. Black hole A has ten times the mass of black hole B. What does Hawking's result say about their temperatures?
    Show answer

    B is about ten times hotter than A, because the temperature falls as the mass rises. The temperature is inversely proportional to the mass, so a black hole with a tenth of the mass is ten times as hot.

  3. What is the best way to understand the picture of particle pairs at the edge of a black hole?
    Show answer

    It is a rough image; Hawking himself called it heuristic, and the real result comes from a calculation. In his 1975 paper Hawking wrote that these pictures should not be taken too literally. The typical wavelength of the radiation is even larger than the black hole.

The takeaway

Hawking radiation is the faint heat that quantum theory predicts a black hole gives off, with a temperature that rises as its mass falls, so a black hole slowly loses mass. A black hole as heavy as the Sun is about 60 billionths of a degree above absolute zero, far colder than the cosmic microwave background, so today it absorbs more than it emits. The popular picture of particle pairs splitting at the edge is only a rough aid, as Hawking himself said, and no real black hole has been seen to radiate. When you learn a theory from a picture, check what the calculation behind it says.

Key quotes

“It should be emphasized that these pictures of the mechanism responsible for the thermal emission and area decrease are heuristic only and should not be taken too literally.”
Stephen Hawking, "Particle Creation by Black Holes", Communications in Mathematical Physics 43 (1975), p. 202

References

  1. Particle Creation by Black Holes. S. W. Hawking, Communications in Mathematical Physics 43, 199–220, 1975

    The full derivation. The first section gives the particle-pair picture and the warning that it is only heuristic.

  2. Hawking radiation, the Stefan-Boltzmann law, and unitarization. Steven B. Giddings, Physics Letters B 754, 39–42, 2016

    A short paper arguing that the radiation comes from a 'quantum atmosphere' about as large as the black hole, not from a thin layer at the horizon.

  3. Observation of quantum Hawking radiation and its entanglement in an analogue black hole. Jeff Steinhauer, Nature Physics 12, 959, 2016

    The experiment in which sound waves in an ultracold gas showed linked pairs on both sides of a sonic horizon.

  4. Observation of thermal Hawking radiation and its temperature in an analogue black hole. Juan Ramón Muñoz de Nova, Katrine Golubkov, Victor I. Kolobov and Jeff Steinhauer, Nature 569, 688–691, 2019

    The follow-up that measured a thermal spectrum at the temperature Hawking's formula predicts for the analogue.

  5. Constraining the Local Burst Rate Density of Primordial Black Holes with HAWC. HAWC Collaboration (A. Albert and others), Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2020 (04), 026, 2020

    A search through 959 days of gamma-ray data for the final bursts of small evaporating black holes, which found none.

hawking-radiationblack-holesblack-hole-evaporationstephen-hawkingevent-horizonquantum-physicsgeneral-relativityblack-hole-thermodynamicsvirtual-particlesanalogue-black-holesjeff-steinhauerbill-unruhprimordial-black-holescosmologyphysics

What Is Entropy?

Why perfume spreads through a room but never gathers back into the bottle. Entropy and the second law, worked out by counting molecules in a box.

5 min read≈ 1,210 words3 questions