Skip to content
mentua.org

"A Brief History of Time" by Stephen Hawking: Summary and Review

Line drawing of space-time as a funnel sinking into a black hole, with a pair of particles at the rim: one falls in, the other escapes on a dotted pathLine drawing of space-time as a funnel sinking into a black hole, with a pair of particles at the rim: one falls in, the other escapes on a dotted path

10 min read≈ 2,310 words5 questions · up to 5 points

What this is about

A Brief History of Time asks whether the universe had a beginning, what happens inside a black hole and why time runs only forward. You learn the nine ideas Stephen Hawking uses to answer these questions, how the book differs from other popular books on the universe, and which of its claims have aged. At the end you know whether to read it, and in which edition.

The book in three sentences· skip ahead

A Brief History of Time explains, without mathematics, how physicists came to see the universe as something that expands and had a beginning. Hawking then shows what happens when the two great theories of physics, general relativity and quantum mechanics, meet: black holes slowly give off heat, and space and time together may have no edge at all. He ends with the hope that a single complete theory will one day let everyone ask why the universe exists.

A Brief History of Time

Author
Stephen Hawking
Published
1988
Publisher
Bantam (Transworld), updated paperback with the author's appendix
Length
272 pages
Audiobook
6h 57m, read by John Sackville
Best for
Curious readers without a science background who want to know how physicists think about the beginning of the universe, black holes and time, told by one of the people who shaped those ideas.

On April 1, 1988, a Cambridge physicist who could no longer speak published a book about the beginning of the universe, black holes and the nature of time. Stephen Hawking had lost his voice in 1985 and wrote with a computer and a speech synthesizer. In his foreword to the 1996 edition he notes that A Brief History of Time stayed on the London Sunday Times best-seller list for 237 weeks. By then it had been translated into about forty languages and had sold roughly one copy for every 750 people in the world. It is one of the most famous science books ever written, and also one that many readers never finish.

What kind of book this is

Hawking decided to write a popular book after giving the Loeb lectures at Harvard in 1982. He believed that the basic ideas about the origin and fate of the universe can be explained without mathematics. Someone had warned him that every equation would halve the sales, so he kept only one, Einstein’s E = mc².

This review follows the book’s argument in nine ideas. The first five mostly describe physics that Hawking inherited, and the last four are where he speaks about his own work.

A theory is a model, and it is always provisional

Hawking opens with a story. After a lecture on astronomy, an old lady tells the speaker that the world is a flat plate on the back of a giant tortoise. When he asks what the tortoise stands on, she answers that it is “turtles all the way down”. Hawking asks why we think our own picture of the universe is better, and his answer is a definition of science. A theory is a model of the universe together with rules that link it to observations, and it is a good theory if it explains many observations with few assumptions and makes definite predictions.

Any physical theory is always provisional, in the sense that it is only a hypothesis: you can never prove it.

Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, ch. 1

Following the philosopher Karl Popper, Hawking adds that one observation can disprove a theory, while no number of observations can prove it. Physicists therefore work with partial theories, each of which describes one range of things, and hope to join them into one complete theory. This hope frames the whole book.

Space and time are part of the universe, not a fixed stage

Chapter 2 explains Einstein’s theories of relativity, which replaced Newton’s idea of one absolute time shared by every clock. In relativity, each observer has their own measure of time, and space and time join into one four-dimensional space-time. In general relativity, mass and energy also curve space-time, and what we feel as gravity is that curvature. The result that matters for the rest of the book is that space and time can change and have a history.

The universe is expanding, so it must have had a beginning

In 1929 the astronomer Edwin Hubble found that distant galaxies are moving away from us, and the farther they are, the faster they move. If the universe is expanding now, it was smaller and denser in the past. Hawking shows that the Russian physicist Alexander Friedmann had already described such a universe in 1922.

Roger Penrose proved in 1965 that a collapsing star must end in a singularity, a point of infinite density. Hawking reversed the direction of time in the argument, and in 1970 he and Penrose published a joint paper showing that, if general relativity is correct, the universe began in a singularity, the big bang. At a singularity all the laws of physics break down, so general relativity predicts its own failure. The rest of the book looks for a theory that does not fail there.

Hawking also uses an old puzzle as evidence. If the universe were infinite and unchanging, almost every line of sight would end on a star, and the night sky would be as bright as the Sun. The dark sky suggests that the stars began to shine at a finite time in the past, as Why Is the Night Sky Dark? Olbers’ Paradox, Explained shows.

The uncertainty principle ends perfect prediction

Chapters 4 and 5 bring in the physics of the very small. At the beginning of the nineteenth century the French scientist Laplace believed that if you knew the state of the universe at one moment, its laws would tell you everything that will happen. Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle shows that this is impossible, because the more exactly you measure a particle’s position, the less exactly you can know its speed. Hawking then describes the particles of matter and the four forces of nature. These are the hardest pages in the book, but you need only one result from them: in the quantum world nothing can be fixed exactly, not even empty space.

Black holes are where gravity wins completely

Chapter 6 tells how black holes were found in theory. On his voyage to England, the young Indian student Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar calculated that a dead star above a certain mass cannot support itself against its own gravity, so it collapses until not even light can escape. The boundary of that region is the event horizon, and Hawking compares it to Dante’s gate of Hell, because whatever crosses it never comes back. He also tells of his bet with the physicist Kip Thorne that the X-ray source Cygnus X-1 did not contain a black hole, a bet he made as insurance for his own work and later conceded.

Black holes are not completely black (“Hawking radiation”)

The chapter “Black Holes Ain’t So Black” describes Hawking’s most famous discovery. A young researcher at Princeton, Jacob Bekenstein, had suggested that the area of a black hole’s event horizon measures its entropy, its amount of disorder. Hawking admits that the idea annoyed him, because anything with entropy must also have a temperature and give off heat, and black holes were not supposed to give off anything.

In late 1973, after discussions in Moscow with Yakov Zeldovich and Alexander Starobinsky, he did the calculation himself and found, to his own surprise, that every black hole should emit particles as if it were a hot body. The explanation comes from the uncertainty principle. Empty space is full of pairs of short-lived particles that appear and disappear. Near a black hole, one member of a pair can fall in while the other escapes, and to a distant observer the escaping particle looks like radiation from the black hole. The energy is paid for by the black hole’s mass, so the black hole slowly shrinks.

For large black holes the effect is tiny, since one a few times the mass of the Sun has a temperature of about one ten-millionth of a degree above absolute zero. In this chapter, gravity, quantum theory and thermodynamics meet for the first time.

Space and time may have no edge (“the no boundary proposal”)

In chapter 8 Hawking turns to the beginning of the universe. At a conference on cosmology organized by the Jesuits in the Vatican in 1981, he says, the Pope told the participants not to inquire into the big bang itself, because that was the moment of Creation. Hawking had just given a talk suggesting that there might be no such moment.

The idea, which he developed with Jim Hartle, uses imaginary time, a mathematical way of measuring time in which there is no difference between time and the directions of space. In imaginary time, space-time could be finite but have no edge, like the surface of the Earth, around which you can sail without falling off. Hawking sums it up in one sentence: “The boundary condition of the universe is that it has no boundary.” If this is right, there is no singularity where the laws break down, and the universe has neither beginning nor end. Hawking then asks what place this leaves for a creator, and that question made the book famous far beyond physics.

The same chapter introduces the anthropic principle: we see the universe as it is because we exist. Hawking accepts the weak version and compares it to a rich person in a wealthy neighborhood who never sees poverty, but he doubts the strong version, which imagines many universes with different laws. Why Does the Universe Seem Fine-Tuned for Life? follows this debate further.

Time has a direction because disorder grows (“the arrow of time”)

Chapter 9 asks why we remember the past but not the future. Hawking names three arrows of time: the thermodynamic arrow, in which disorder increases; the psychological arrow, in which we feel time pass; and the cosmological arrow, in which the universe expands. A cup can fall and break, but the pieces never jump back onto the table, because there are far more disordered states than ordered ones, as What Is Entropy? explains.

Hawking argues that memory follows the thermodynamic arrow. A computer that stores a fact produces more disorder as heat than it gains as order in its memory, and he assumes the brain works the same way.

Disorder increases with time because we measure time in the direction in which disorder increases.

Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, ch. “The Arrow of Time”

The no boundary proposal then explains why the universe began in a smooth, ordered state, so that disorder had room to grow. Hawking also admits a mistake here. He first believed that disorder would decrease if the universe ever collapsed again. His colleague Don Page and his student Raymond Laflamme showed him he was wrong, and he says that it is better to admit such a mistake in print.

A complete theory would let us ask why the universe exists

The last chapters return to the hope from chapter 1. Hawking describes the attempts to unify all forces in one theory and gives special attention to string theory. In 1988 he expected physicists to know by the year 2000 whether it was the unified theory they were looking for. The later editions add a chapter on wormholes, in which he suggests that the laws of physics prevent travel into the past.

In the conclusion, Hawking notes that even a complete theory would be only a set of rules and equations, and it would not say why there is a universe for them to describe. He hopes that such a theory could be understood in broad outline by everyone, so that all of us could discuss why we and the universe exist. If we found the answer, he writes in the book’s most quoted line, we would know “the mind of God”.

How it differs from other books on the universe

A Brief History of Time is unusual because its author explains a field that he himself shaped. Three neighbours show what this means.

  • Steven Weinberg’s The First Three Minutes (1977), which Hawking praises in his acknowledgments, tells the story of the early universe with more concrete physics and more numbers, but it stops before black holes and the question of a creator.
  • Brian Greene’s The Elegant Universe (1999) explains string theory at length, a subject that gets only a few pages in Hawking.
  • A Briefer History of Time (2005), written by Hawking with the physicist Leonard Mlodinow, rewrites and updates the same material for a wider audience. It is easier, but less personal.

The personal voice is what makes the original stand out. Hawking writes with dry humour and tells you about his bets, his irritation with rivals and his changes of mind, so you see how research feels from the inside.

Where it falls short

The book has three weaknesses. The first is difficulty. It has no equations, but it compresses relativity, quantum theory and particle physics into a few short chapters, and ideas such as imaginary time are stated more than explained. In 2014 the mathematician Jordan Ellenberg checked where the most popular Kindle highlights fall in bestsellers. For this book they came on average only 6.6 percent of the way through, which suggests that many buyers stop early.

The second weakness is age. String theory was not settled by 2000. In 1988 Hawking still discussed whether the universe would one day collapse, but in 1998 astronomers found that its expansion is speeding up. In the 2017 appendix Hawking also reports that in 2004 he changed his mind about black holes, which he had thought destroy information for ever.

The third weakness is that Hawking presents his own ideas with more confidence than the evidence allows. Hawking radiation has never been observed from a real black hole, only in laboratory models, such as the experiment with sound in an ultracold gas that Jeff Steinhauer reported in 2016. Hawking’s 2017 appendix sees support for the no boundary proposal in the cosmic microwave background, but it remains unconfirmed. In 2017 the physicists Job Feldbrugge, Jean-Luc Lehners and Neil Turok argued that it predicts an irregular universe unlike ours. The remarks about God are more provocative than careful, because the book raises the question in a few pages and never argues it out.

Which edition and format to choose

Choose an updated edition with the 2017 appendix, such as the current Bantam paperback described in this review. Its appendix on dark energy, gravitational waves and other discoveries shows which of Hawking’s ideas held up. If you find space-time hard, The Illustrated A Brief History of Time (1996) adds colour pictures that make these chapters easier to follow.

Print or ebook works best, because the diagrams in chapters 2 and 3 carry part of the argument. The unabridged audiobook, read by John Sackville, lasts just under seven hours and suits a second reading, but the middle chapters are hard to follow without the figures. Read one chapter at a time, and do not give up in chapters 4 and 5, because the best part comes after them.

Quiz

5 questions · up to 5 points

Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.

  1. What does Hawking say about every physical theory in chapter 1?
    Show answer

    It is always provisional: experiments can disprove it, but no number of experiments can prove it. Hawking follows the philosopher Karl Popper here. A good theory makes predictions that a single observation could show to be false.

  2. Why does a black hole slowly lose mass, according to chapter 7?
    Show answer

    Quantum effects near the event horizon let it give off particles, and the energy for them comes from the black hole's mass. This is Hawking radiation. One particle of a short-lived pair falls in with negative energy, its partner escapes, and the black hole shrinks.

  3. What does the 'no boundary' proposal claim about the universe?
    Show answer

    Space and time together may form a finite surface without an edge, like the surface of the Earth in more dimensions. Hawking and Jim Hartle proposed it. If it holds, there is no starting point where the laws of physics break down.

  4. How does Hawking explain why we remember the past but not the future?
    Show answer

    Recording a memory increases the total disorder of the universe, so we remember in the direction in which disorder grows. Hawking argues that the psychological arrow of time follows the thermodynamic arrow, using a computer's memory as his example.

  5. What does this review suggest about how to read the book today?
    Show answer

    Read an updated edition with the appendix, slowly, and take the chapters on particles and forces one at a time. The appendix shows which ideas held up, and the middle chapters are where most readers give up.

The takeaway

A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking explains how physics found that the universe expands and had a beginning, and what happens where general relativity and quantum theory meet. Its best ideas are Hawking's own: black holes give off radiation, space-time may have 'no boundary', and time has a direction because disorder grows. The middle chapters are hard, and some predictions have aged, so read an updated edition slowly, with its appendix. Above all, the book teaches you to treat every theory as provisional, including Hawking's own.

Key quotes

“It seems to me much better and less confusing if you admit in print that you were wrong.”
Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, ch. "The Arrow of Time"
“What is it that breathes fire into the equations and makes a universe for them to describe?”
Stephen Hawking, A Brief History of Time, Conclusion

Should you read it?

Read it if

  • You want to understand where ideas like the big bang, black holes and the 'theory of everything' come from, without equations.
  • You are curious how a leading physicist reasons about God, time and the limits of science.
  • You like a scientist who tells you about his own bets, mistakes and changes of mind.

Skip it if

  • You want the current state of cosmology; the main text dates from 1988 and 1996, and only a short appendix brings it up to date.
  • You lose patience with abstract chapters; the middle of the book on particles and forces is dense, and many readers stop there.
  • You want a careful philosophical answer to whether God exists; Hawking raises the question but argues it only briefly.

As an Amazon Associate, mentua.org earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and never shapes the verdict.

Ideas from this book

References

  1. A Brief History Of Time: From Big Bang To Black Holes. Stephen Hawking, Bantam (Penguin Random House)

    The publisher's page for the updated paperback described in this review.

  2. Black hole explosions?. S. W. Hawking, Nature 248, 1974

    Hawking's short paper predicting that black holes give off radiation, the result behind chapter 7.

  3. No smooth beginning for spacetime. Job Feldbrugge, Jean-Luc Lehners and Neil Turok, Physical Review Letters 119, 2017

    A critique arguing that the no boundary proposal predicts an irregular universe unlike ours.

a-brief-history-of-timestephen-hawkingcosmologybig-bangblack-holeshawking-radiationno-boundary-proposalimaginary-timearrow-of-timeentropyanthropic-principlegeneral-relativityquantum-mechanicsstring-theoryphysicsbook-reviewsummary

What Is Entropy?

Why perfume spreads through a room but never gathers back into the bottle. Entropy and the second law, worked out by counting molecules in a box.

5 min read≈ 1,200 words3 questions