Skip to content
mentua.org

What Was the Printing Revolution?

Line drawing of a frame of movable type with one filled piece, a dotted arrow and a stack of three identical printed pagesLine drawing of a frame of movable type with one filled piece, a dotted arrow and a stack of three identical printed pages

5 min read≈ 1,210 words3 questions · up to 3 points

What this is about

Before about 1450, every book in Europe was copied by hand, and no two copies were the same. You learn what changed when copies stopped drifting apart, how one printed book let astronomers correct and build on each other's work, and why some historians think the change was less automatic than it looks.

In a nutshell· skip ahead

The printing revolution is the name for the changes that followed movable-type printing in Europe after about 1450. Print made hundreds of identical copies of one text. Readers in different places could now refer to the same page, compare it, correct it in the next edition and build on it. The same machine also copied errors and pirated texts.

Before about 1450, every book in Europe was copied by hand. A scribe copied from an older copy, and every copy added a few new mistakes, so no two books were exactly the same. Fifty years later, printers in about 280 towns had produced some 30,000 editions. Historians agree that this was a big change, but they disagree about what kind of change it was: did print only make more books, or did it change what people could know?

What changed when books were printed instead of copied by hand?

The printing revolution is the name historians give to the changes that followed movable-type printing in Europe. Movable type means single metal letters that a printer arranges into lines and pages, prints from, and then takes apart and reuses. Johannes Gutenberg is credited with building such a system in Mainz around 1450, and his Bible appeared in about 1455 in roughly 180 copies, according to the Library of Congress.

The American historian Elizabeth Eisenstein argued in 1979 that the speed of print mattered less than its sameness. A scribe produced one copy at a time, and each copy drifted a little further from the original. A printer set the type once and then printed hundreds of copies with the same words on the same pages. Eisenstein called the result typographical fixity: a text that stays the same in every copy and survives because so many copies exist.

Identical copies had three effects. Readers far apart could point to the same page and know they were reading the same words. They could compare one book with another, and see where two authors disagreed. And they could send corrections to the printer, who fixed them in the next edition, so errors were removed for every reader instead of being multiplied by each new copyist.

How did one printed book change astronomy?

Copernicus’s theory that the Earth moves around the Sun shows these effects step by step.

  1. A handwritten start. Around 1510 to 1514, Copernicus wrote a short sketch of his idea. It circulated in a few handwritten copies among scholars, but it was never printed.
  2. One printed edition. In 1543 the printer Johann Petreius in Nuremberg published Copernicus’s full book, De revolutionibus. Hundreds of copies carried the same tables and diagrams on the same pages.
  3. Shared corrections. Erasmus Reinhold, a professor of astronomy at Wittenberg, wrote corrections to some of Copernicus’s calculations in the margins of his copy. Students copied notes like his into their own copies, which worked because every copy had the same words in the same place on the same page.
  4. New work built on it. In 1551 Reinhold published the Prutenic Tables, the first planetary tables computed from the Copernican system. Astronomers used them more widely than the older tables, although Reinhold himself did not believe that the Earth moves.

The surprising part came four hundred years later, after the writer Arthur Koestler had called De revolutionibus “the book that nobody read”. The Harvard astronomer Owen Gingerich spent about thirty years looking for surviving copies and found 601 of the first two editions, many of them full of notes by serious astronomers. Because the printed copies started out identical, every handwritten mark stood out as the trace of a real reader, and Gingerich could follow how ideas passed from teacher to student.

What the printing revolution teaches you

Cheap, exact copies change knowledge most when they give many people one shared version to check, but they also spread every mistake to every reader. So ask two questions about any copied text. Which version am I reading? Who stands behind it? Who Vouches for a Copy? Why Every Information Revolution Is About Trust follows the second question through history.

  • Studies. A teacher asks you to give the edition and page of a quote, because only then can someone else find exactly the words you read. A quote of a quote, copied from site to site, drifts like a hand-copied manuscript.
  • News. A screenshot of a post travels unchanged to millions of phones, but nobody can tell from the copy whether the original was real. You still have to trace it back to its source.
  • Work. Ten copies of a plan sent by email drift apart like scribal copies. One shared document with a version history gives the team a fixed text that everybody corrects together.

The idea also helps when people call the internet or artificial intelligence “a new printing revolution”. The useful question is whether they create shared, checkable versions, or only more copies.

For digital copies, there is now a technical way to check who stands behind a text, the digital signature, explained in What Is Public-Key Cryptography?.

Did printing make texts reliable on its own?

A common mistake is to think that print made texts trustworthy automatically. The historian Adrian Johns argued in The Nature of the Book (1998) that fixity had to be built. Early printers changed the texts they printed, often corrected pages while the press was already running, so even copies of one edition could differ, and pirates reprinted popular books without permission. Johns writes that by about 1525, unauthorized copies of Luther’s German Bible appeared at “a rate ninety times” that of Luther’s own printers.

Piracy pervaded the world of print, making any book difficult to trust.

Adrian Johns, Ten Things You Didn’t Know about Your Books (1998)

Errors spread in the same way. In 1631 the king’s printer in London produced a Bible whose seventh commandment had lost the word “not”, so every copy told readers to commit adultery. The printer was heavily fined, and trust in print came only slowly, through careful printers, licensing and, later, copyright laws.

The second limit is that technology alone does not explain the changes. Bi Sheng made movable type from baked clay in China around 1040, and the oldest surviving book printed with metal movable type, the Jikji, was made in Korea in 1377. Neither led to the same changes as in Europe, partly because Chinese script needs thousands of characters and woodblock printing already worked well. Eisenstein’s own title calls the press “an agent of change”, which means one cause among several, not the single cause of the Reformation or of modern science.

Learn more

The idea that printing changed the world is older than the term. In 1620 the English philosopher Francis Bacon named printing, gunpowder and the compass as three inventions that had changed the world. In 1962 the media theorist Marshall McLuhan argued in The Gutenberg Galaxy that print changed how people think. Elizabeth Eisenstein turned the idea into a historical thesis in The Printing Press as an Agent of Change (1979), and Adrian Johns gave the strongest answer to it in 1998. So no single person is the originator of the idea.

For the larger story of how shared stories and records let humans cooperate, read “Sapiens” by Yuval Noah Harari: Summary and Review. For a record that was hard to fake long before print, read What Were Tally Sticks?. If you want Eisenstein’s argument in one volume, her shorter version is The Printing Revolution in Early Modern Europe (Affiliate Link).

Quiz

3 questions · up to 3 points

Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.

  1. According to Elizabeth Eisenstein, what was the most important difference between printed books and hand-copied books?
    Show answer

    Print produced many identical copies, so readers in different places could compare and correct the same text. Identical copies gave readers a shared reference. A correction could go into the next edition instead of disappearing in a single copy.

  2. A team keeps its project plan as one shared online document with a version history, instead of emailing copies back and forth. Which part of the printing revolution does this repeat?
    Show answer

    Everyone works from the same fixed text, so mistakes can be found and fixed for all readers at once. This is the advantage Eisenstein saw in print: one shared version that many people can check and correct.

  3. What did the historian Adrian Johns argue against the idea that print fixed texts?
    Show answer

    Reliable printed texts were not automatic; printers, readers and laws had to make print trustworthy, because errors and piracy were common. Johns showed that printers changed texts and pirates reprinted them, so trust in print had to be built over time.

The takeaway

The printing revolution is the series of changes that followed movable-type printing in Europe after about 1450. Print produced hundreds of identical copies, so readers far apart could compare the same page, correct it and build on it, as astronomers did with Copernicus's book of 1543. Print did not make texts reliable on its own, because errors and pirated editions spread just as fast. With any copied text, ask which version it is and who stands behind it.

Key quotes

“Piracy pervaded the world of print, making any book difficult to trust.”
Adrian Johns, Ten Things You Didn't Know about Your Books, University of Chicago Press, 1998

References

  1. The Printing Press as an Agent of Change. Elizabeth L. Eisenstein, Cambridge University Press, 1979

    The publisher's page for the book that made the printing revolution a historical thesis, with its table of contents.

  2. Ten Things You Didn't Know about Your Books. Adrian Johns, University of Chicago Press, 1998

    A short piece by Eisenstein's best-known critic on printers who changed texts, the 1631 'wicked' Bible and early piracy.

  3. The Gutenberg Bible. Library of Congress

    How many copies of Gutenberg's Bible were printed, on what material, and how many survive.

  4. Nicolaus Copernicus. Sheila Rabin, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023

    How Copernicus's handwritten sketch and his printed book of 1543 reached readers, including Reinhold's tables.

  5. Hot on the trail of Copernicus. Job Kozhamthadam, Physics World, 2004

    A review of Owen Gingerich's search for surviving copies of Copernicus's book and what their notes show.

printing-revolutionprinting-pressmovable-typejohannes-gutenbergelizabeth-eisensteinadrian-johnsprint-culturehistory-of-the-booktypographical-fixitycopernicusde-revolutionibusscientific-revolutionreformationearly-modern-europemedia-historyinformation-technology