"Utilitarianism" by John Stuart Mill: Summary and Review


10 min read≈ 2,280 words5 questions · up to 5 points
What this is about
In 1861 John Stuart Mill set out to defend a moral theory that many readers of his time thought was fit only for pigs. You learn the seven claims of his short book, how he answers the objections people still raise today, and why his famous proof has been attacked for more than a century. At the end you know whether to read the book and which edition to choose.
The book in three sentences· skip ahead
Mill argues that an action is right in so far as it tends to promote happiness, counting everyone's happiness equally. He defends this principle against its critics by separating higher from lower pleasures, by showing that everyday moral rules can serve it, and by explaining justice as its most important part. The payoff is a humane version of utilitarianism that remains the starting point for every debate about it.
Utilitarianism
- Author
- John Stuart Mill
- Published
- 1861
- Publisher
- Hackett Publishing (2nd edition, edited by George Sher, with the 1868 speech on capital punishment)
- Length
- 88 pages
- Audiobook
- 3h 6m, read by Fleet Cooper
- Best for
- Readers who want to know what utilitarianism really claims, in the words of its most careful classic defender, before they judge it.
John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarianism claims that one simple test, how much happiness an action tends to produce for everyone affected, can explain the whole of morality, including justice. Mill (1806 to 1873) was one of the leading English philosophers of his day. He wrote the book for the general reader of Fraser’s Magazine, where it appeared as three articles in 1861 before it came out as a book in 1863. At the time, many readers thought that the theory of Jeremy Bentham, in which Mill had been raised, was cold, selfish or fit only for animals. Mill’s book is a reply to them, and it is still the text most people read when they first meet the theory.
Right actions are those that tend to promote happiness (the “Greatest Happiness Principle”)
Mill’s central claim is the Greatest Happiness Principle, which says that an action is right to the degree that it tends to produce happiness and wrong to the degree that it tends to produce the opposite. By happiness Mill means pleasure and the absence of pain. Everything else people value, such as health, knowledge or friendship, is valuable either as a part of happiness or as a means to it.
Mill begins chapter 2 by clearing away a misunderstanding of the word itself. In ordinary speech, “utility” meant the dull and practical, the opposite of pleasure, so people assumed that utilitarians despised enjoyment. Mill says the reverse is true, since the theory is about pleasure from start to finish. If you want the theory itself in five minutes, with a worked example from a health budget, read What Is Utilitarianism? first.
Some pleasures are higher in quality, and “competent judges” decide which
Mill’s most famous move is to say that pleasures differ in quality, not only in amount. Critics had called utilitarianism “a doctrine worthy only of swine”, because it seemed to say that life has no higher aim than pleasure. Mill replies that human beings have higher faculties, and that the pleasures of the intellect, the feelings and the imagination are worth more than those of mere sensation.
To decide which of two pleasures is higher, Mill proposes a test. Ask people who know both well. If almost all of them firmly prefer one, even though it brings more discontent, that one is higher in quality. Mill thinks the result is not in doubt, because hardly anyone would agree to become an animal or a fool in exchange for an animal’s or a fool’s pleasures. He explains the preference by “a sense of dignity”, which all human beings have in some form.
It is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied; better to be Socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied.
This passage gave the theory a human face, but it also creates a problem that later critics pressed hard, which we return to below.
The standard is everyone’s happiness, and it judges acts, not motives
Mill insists that the happiness that counts is not your own but that of everyone affected by what you do. You must be as impartial between yourself and others as a “disinterested and benevolent spectator”. He even says that the Golden Rule of Jesus, to do as you would be done by and to love your neighbor as yourself, contains the whole spirit of utilitarian ethics.
Mill then separates the rule of action from the motive behind it. Someone who saves a drowning man does what is right, whether he acts from duty or in the hope of a reward, and the motive tells us only how good the person is. This answers the complaint that utilitarianism asks people to think about the whole world all the time. Most good actions, Mill says, are meant for particular people, and very few people ever have the power to do good on a large scale.
Mill also claims the noble side of self-sacrifice for his theory. He honors people who give up their own happiness, but only when the sacrifice increases the happiness of others, and he says that a sacrifice which does not do this is wasted. In the same passage he praises the calm of the Stoics who lived through the worst times of the Roman Empire, the attitude you meet in “Meditations” by Marcus Aurelius: Summary and Review.
Everyday moral rules are “secondary principles” that carry humanity’s experience
The most practical idea in the book is Mill’s answer to the objection that nobody has time to calculate consequences before acting. He replies that humanity has had time, namely its whole history, to learn which kinds of action help or harm. Rules such as “do not steal” and “keep your promises” carry this experience, and Mill calls them secondary principles: rules that serve the first principle without replacing it.
Mill compares the situation to sailing. Sailors do not work out the positions of the stars at sea; they take a ready-made table with them, and in the same way all reasonable people go through life with the common moral questions already settled. He offers a second image too: telling a traveler where he is going does not forbid him to use the signposts on the way. The first principle is needed only when two secondary principles conflict, for example when keeping a promise would cause serious harm.
Scholars still disagree about what this means. Some read Mill as a “rule utilitarian”, who judges acts by the rules they follow, and others as an “act utilitarian”, who judges each act by its own results and treats rules as reliable shortcuts. The text supports both readings in places, and Mill never settles the question.
Conscience and the “social feelings” give the principle its binding force
Chapter 3 asks why anyone should feel bound by the principle. Mill calls this the question of the sanction, meaning the motives that make people obey a moral rule. He answers that utilitarianism has the same sanctions as any other morality. The external ones are the hope of approval and the fear of disapproval from other people or from God. The internal one is conscience, which Mill describes as a feeling of pain in your own mind when you break a duty.
Mill admits that moral feelings are not innate but learned, which could make them look arbitrary. His answer is that they grow from something natural, the social feelings of mankind, above all “the desire to be in unity with our fellow creatures”. As society develops, people get used to treating others as equals and to working toward shared goals, so caring about the general good becomes part of their character. This chapter is short and more hopeful than argued, but it shows that Mill expected education and public opinion to do much of morality’s work.
Happiness is desirable because people desire it (Mill’s “proof”)
Chapter 4 offers what Mill calls a proof, although he warns in chapter 1 that ultimate ends cannot be proved directly. His argument runs from the evidence of experience, in a sentence that has been quoted ever since.
the sole evidence it is possible to produce that anything is desirable, is that people do actually desire it.
The argument has three steps. Just as the only proof that something is visible is that people see it, the only proof that happiness is desirable is that people desire it. Since each person desires his own happiness, Mill concludes that the general happiness is a good to all persons taken together. Finally, people seem to desire other things, such as virtue, but Mill argues that these become parts of happiness. His example is money: at first it is wanted only for what it buys, but the miser comes to love it for itself, so it becomes part of what happiness means to him.
This chapter is the most discussed and the most criticized part of the book, and it is worth reading twice, because each step claims a little more than it seems to.
Justice is the most important part of utility, not its rival
Chapter 5 is the longest in the book, about a third of the whole, and it takes on what Mill calls “the only real difficulty” for his theory. People feel that justice is something absolute, quite different from what is merely useful, so a theory of happiness seems unable to explain it.
Mill starts by listing what people call unjust: violating someone’s legal or moral rights, giving people what they do not deserve, breaking faith, being partial and treating people unequally. What these cases share, he argues, is a wrong done to an assignable person who has a right. A right in Mill’s sense is a claim that society ought to protect. Charity is a duty too, but nobody in particular can demand it from you, so failing to give is not unjust.
Why should society protect rights so firmly? Mill’s answer is security. Most goods can be given up or replaced, but nobody can live without the safety of person and property, and this interest is so vital that the feeling around it changes from “ought” into “must”. Justice, then, is Mill’s name for the moral rules that matter most for the general happiness, and so bind more strongly than any others. Mill adds that the history of social progress has been a series of customs that came to be seen as injustices, from slavery to serfdom, and he predicts the same for “the aristocracies of colour, race, and sex”.
Mill also accepts that justice can be overruled. To save a life, he writes, it may be a duty to steal food or medicine, or even to kidnap the only doctor who can help. This honesty is admirable, but it shows that Mill’s rights are strong rules of utility, not barriers that utility can never cross.
How it differs from Bentham, Kant and the modern critics
Against Jeremy Bentham’s An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation (1789), Mill’s book is shorter, gentler and less systematic. Bentham counted pleasures by intensity and duration and treated all of them as the same kind, while Mill adds quality, defends secondary principles and gives a full account of justice. Bentham wrote for lawmakers, and Mill wrote for readers who suspected that the theory had no heart.
Against Immanuel Kant’s Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), Mill is openly hostile. In chapter 1 he says that when Kant tries to derive real duties from his principle, he “fails, almost grotesquely”, because Kant can show only that the consequences of everyone following an immoral rule would be bad. Kant’s own view is explained in What Is the Categorical Imperative?, and reading the two side by side shows the basic choice in modern ethics between results and duties.
Against modern books, Mill reads as the opening speech of a debate that is still going on. In the 1973 book Utilitarianism: For and Against, the philosopher J. J. C. Smart defends a stricter version, and Bernard Williams argues that the theory leaves no room for a person’s integrity. For a guided tour that sets Mill next to Kant, Rawls and Aristotle on real cases, read “Justice: What’s the Right Thing to Do?” by Michael J. Sandel: Summary and Review.
Where the argument falls short
The book has three serious weaknesses, and the first is the proof. In Principia Ethica (1903), G. E. Moore replied that “desirable” does not mean “able to be desired” in the way that “visible” means “able to be seen”; it means what ought to be desired. Mill’s step from each person’s happiness to the general happiness is also weak, because the fact that each person wants his own happiness does not show that anyone wants everyone’s.
The second weakness is the higher pleasures. If competent judges prefer Socrates’ life even when it contains less pleasure, then they are valuing something other than pleasure, and Mill’s hedonism is no longer pure. Critics from T. H. Green to Moore have made this point, and Mill never fully answers it.
The third weakness is justice. Mill’s rights hold only as long as protecting them produces more happiness, so the theory cannot fully exclude sacrificing an innocent person when the numbers are large enough. This is the worry behind the cases discussed in What Is the Trolley Problem?. Some of the language is also dated, such as Mill’s contrast between civilization and “savage independence”, although his attack on inequality of race and sex was ahead of most of his contemporaries.
Which edition to read
The book is short, about 90 pages in a modern paperback, and its text is in the public domain, so a free ebook from Project Gutenberg is enough for a first look. For real study, choose a printed edition with an introduction and notes. The Hackett edition, edited by George Sher, is a compact student edition that adds Mill’s 1868 speech on capital punishment, while the Oxford World’s Classics volume combines the book with On Liberty and other essays.
The unabridged audiobook read by Fleet Cooper lasts about three hours and suits chapters 2 and 3, which argue through examples. Chapters 4 and 5 are harder by ear, because Mill’s long sentences carry qualifications that you need to see on the page. If you have little time, read chapter 2, where Mill defines the theory and answers the objections, and chapter 5 on justice, which together make up about two thirds of the book.
Quiz
5 questions · up to 5 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
According to Mill's Greatest Happiness Principle, what makes an action right?
Show answer
It tends to promote happiness, counting the happiness of everyone affected equally Mill defines the principle in chapter 2 and adds that the standard is the happiness of all concerned, not the agent's own, judged as an impartial spectator would.
How does Mill decide whether reading poetry is a higher pleasure than eating a good meal?
Show answer
He asks which one people who know both well firmly prefer, even when it brings more discontent This is Mill's test of competent judges in chapter 2. A pleasure is higher in quality if almost everyone who has experienced both prefers it.
A critic says utilitarianism is useless because nobody has time to calculate all consequences before acting. What is Mill's reply?
Show answer
Humanity has already learned the effects of actions, and ordinary moral rules carry that experience, as a sailor uses a ready-made almanac Mill calls these rules secondary principles. They are used day to day, and the first principle is needed only when two of them conflict.
Why do critics such as G. E. Moore reject Mill's proof that happiness is desirable?
Show answer
Because 'desirable' means what ought to be desired, not what can be desired, as 'visible' means what can be seen Mill compared 'desirable' with 'visible' and 'audible' in chapter 4. Moore replied in 1903 that the comparison hides the very question of what people ought to want.
What does this review recommend for a first reading of the book?
Show answer
Read chapters 2 and 5 first in a printed edition with notes, then the short chapters 3 and 4 Chapter 2 holds the theory and the replies to objections, and chapter 5 holds the account of justice, which together make up about two thirds of the book.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: What Is Utilitarianism? →The takeaway
Utilitarianism by John Stuart Mill defends the Greatest Happiness Principle: actions are right in so far as they tend to promote the happiness of everyone affected, each counted equally. Mill adds that some pleasures are higher in quality, that ordinary moral rules work as secondary principles, and that justice is the most important part of utility. His proof that happiness is desirable is weak, and his account of rights is less firm than it sounds. Read chapters 2 and 5 first, and use his test to ask who gains and who loses from a rule you follow.
Key quotes
“actions are right in proportion as they tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.”
“Nobody argues that the art of navigation is not founded on astronomy, because sailors cannot wait to calculate the Nautical Almanack.”
“To have a right, then, is, I conceive, to have something which society ought to defend me in the possession of.”
Should you read it?
Read it if
- You want to understand utilitarianism from the source, because modern debates about charity, health budgets or animal welfare start from it.
- You want to see a philosopher answer the standard objections one by one, from 'a doctrine for pigs' to 'nobody has time to calculate'.
- You want a short classic that you can read in two or three evenings and discuss with others.
Skip it if
- You want a modern, rigorous version of the theory, because Mill's proof is loose and he leaves the choice between act and rule versions open.
- You find long Victorian sentences tiring and would rather read a clear modern introduction first.
- You want the strongest case against utilitarianism, which you will find in later critics such as Bernard Williams.
As an Amazon Associate, mentua.org earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and never shapes the verdict.
Ideas from this book
References
- Utilitarianism (Project Gutenberg eBook #11224). John Stuart Mill, Project Gutenberg (text of the seventh edition, Longmans, Green, 1879)
The full public-domain text used for every quotation in this review.
- Mill's Moral and Political Philosophy. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
A detailed scholarly account of the proof, the higher pleasures, secondary principles and Mill's view of justice and rights.
- Principia Ethica. G. E. Moore, 1903
Chapter 3 contains the famous attack on Mill's proof that what is desired is desirable.





