Skip to content
mentua.org

"Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?" by Michael J. Sandel: Summary and Review

Line drawing of a balance whose lower pan holds a flute with finger holes, while the higher pan holds a dotted stack of coinsLine drawing of a balance whose lower pan holds a flute with finger holes, while the higher pan holds a dotted stack of coins

9 min read≈ 2,030 words5 questions · up to 5 points

What this is about

After a hurricane, should a shop be allowed to sell a two-dollar bag of ice for ten dollars? Michael Sandel uses questions like this to walk through the great theories of justice taught in his famous Harvard course. You learn what each theory says, how Sandel tests it against hard cases, what his own position is, and why some critics think the contest is not quite fair.

The book in three sentences· skip ahead

Sandel argues that every debate about justice turns on one of three ideas: making people better off, respecting their freedom, or honoring virtue. He tests utilitarianism, libertarianism, Kant and Rawls against hard cases and finds that none can stay neutral about what goods are for. His conclusion is that a just society has to reason in public about the good life and the common good.

Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?

Author
Michael J. Sandel
Published
2009
Publisher
Farrar, Straus and Giroux (paperback, 2010)
Length
320 pages
Audiobook
15h 58m, read by Michael J. Sandel
Best for
Readers who want one clear map of the main theories of justice, tested on real cases, before they read the philosophers themselves.

Michael Sandel’s Justice argues that you cannot decide what is fair without asking what things are for and which qualities a society should honor. He wrote it in 2009 as the book of his Harvard course “Justice”, whose filmed lectures were shown on public television and are free to watch online. The book keeps the course’s method: it starts from a real case, asks the reader to judge it, and then shows which philosophy the judgment depends on.

Every argument about justice rests on welfare, freedom or virtue

Sandel’s first claim is that debates about justice keep returning to three ideas, and he finds all three in one case. In the summer of 2004, after Hurricane Charley hit Florida, a gas station in Orlando sold two-dollar bags of ice for ten dollars, and the state used its law against price gouging, which means charging unfair prices in an emergency. Economists such as Thomas Sowell defended the high prices because they bring more ice to where it is needed, while the attorney general argued that buyers in an emergency are not really free. Sandel’s diagnosis is that the debate turns on welfare, freedom and virtue, since many people also thought that greed in a disaster deserves blame.

the arguments for and against price-gouging laws revolve around three ideas: maximizing welfare, respecting freedom, and promoting virtue.

Michael J. Sandel, Justice, chapter 1

The same chapter introduces the runaway trolley. In Sandel’s version you are the driver who can turn onto a side track and kill one worker instead of five, and then an onlooker who could push a heavy man off a bridge. He asks why the first seems right and the second wrong, and admits that cases like this remove the uncertainty of real life. The full puzzle, and why philosophers still argue about it, is explained in What Is the Trolley Problem?. Sandel uses the trolley to show his method, which moves back and forth between judgments about cases and the principles behind them:

We sometimes think of moral reasoning as a way of persuading other people. But it is also a way of sorting out our own moral convictions, of figuring out what we believe and why.

Michael J. Sandel, Justice, chapter 1

Utilitarianism counts well but cannot protect rights or price everything

The first theory is utilitarianism, the view of Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill that the right act is the one that produces the most happiness overall. Sandel gives it credit for taking numbers seriously and then raises two objections.

The first is that it fails to respect individual rights. If enough Romans enjoyed watching Christians thrown to the lions, a strict calculation could approve it. Sandel sharpens the point with a ticking-bomb case. Torturing a terrorist suspect may feel justified because we think he is guilty, but if the only way to make him talk were to torture his innocent young daughter, Sandel suspects that even a convinced utilitarian would hesitate.

The second objection is that not all values can be measured on one scale. Sandel’s examples come from real cost-benefit studies. In the 1970s Ford decided that an eleven-dollar safety part for the Pinto’s fuel tank was not worth its cost, after valuing each death at 200,000 dollars. In 2003 the US Environmental Protection Agency valued the lives of people over seventy at less than younger lives, until protests made it withdraw the report. Sandel lets the utilitarian answer that we already trade lives for speed on every highway, and leaves the reader to decide.

Libertarians say we own ourselves, and markets test that claim

The second theory starts from freedom. Libertarians such as Robert Nozick, Milton Friedman and Friedrich Hayek hold that each person owns himself, so justice means respecting voluntary choices and taxing people’s earnings is close to forced labor. Sandel uses the basketball player Michael Jordan to make the claim concrete: if the state takes part of his income, it claims part of his work.

Sandel gives this view a fair hearing. He admits that most standard objections to it can be answered, and then pushes it to its own limit with a case of cannibalism between consenting adults, which a consistent libertarian would have to allow. He follows with a chapter on markets and morals. In the American Civil War a drafted man could pay a substitute to fight for him, and in the 1980s the “Baby M” case in New Jersey asked whether a woman could sell her pregnancy by contract. Sandel’s question is whether such deals are truly free when people face hard pressure, and whether some goods lose their meaning when they are bought.

This is where Justice meets Who Gets What and Why. Alvin Roth, an economist, treats the feeling that some markets are wrong as a limit that market designers must respect, while Sandel asks whether that feeling is right.

Kant grounds morality in autonomy, not in wants or results

Immanuel Kant offers a more demanding idea of freedom. For Kant, Sandel explains, you are free only when you act on a law you give yourself as a rational being, which Kant calls autonomy. Acting on desires, even kind ones, is not freedom but being pushed by nature. The law that reason gives is the categorical imperative, a rule that holds without conditions, and one of its forms says that we must treat persons always as ends and never merely as means.

Sandel teaches Kant through four contrasts: duty against inclination, autonomy against heteronomy (being ruled by outside forces), categorical against hypothetical imperatives, and the “intelligible” world of reason against the “sensible” world of nature. His example shows why this is not the Golden Rule. If your frail mother asks about your brother, who has just died, the Golden Rule asks how you would want to be treated, while Kant asks what it means to respect her as a rational being. On that view, lying to her out of kindness may use her as a means to her own comfort.

Rawls’s veil of ignorance turns luck into a question of justice

John Rawls asks which principles we would choose in an original position of equality, behind a veil of ignorance, where nobody knows whether they will be rich or poor, talented or not. Rawls argues that we would choose equal basic liberties first and then the difference principle, which allows social and economic inequalities only when they work to the benefit of the least advantaged. Higher pay for doctors passes this test if it brings better care to the poor, and fails it if it only produces more cosmetic surgeons.

The core of the chapter is Rawls’s argument from moral arbitrariness. A feudal society hands out life chances by birth, a free market with equal legal rights still lets family background decide, and even a fair meritocracy with good schools for all lets the fastest runners win. Being fast is luck as well, so Rawls concludes that no one deserves his natural talents. Sandel shows that this need not lead to forced equality. Rawls lets the gifted use their talents, but treats what they earn as partly shared with those who lack such gifts. How the thought experiment works, and why real groups behind the veil chose differently from Rawls, is explained in What Is the Veil of Ignorance?.

Aristotle says justice depends on what a good is for

After a chapter that applies these theories to affirmative action, Sandel turns to the view he finds most promising. For Aristotle, justice means giving people what they are due, and you can only know what they are due by asking about the purpose, or telos, of the thing being shared. The best flutes should go to the best flute players, because that is what flutes are for. This kind of reasoning from purpose is called teleological.

Sandel shows that the question has not gone away. The golfer Casey Martin, who had a serious circulation disorder, asked to use a golf cart on the professional tour, and the case went to the US Supreme Court. Sandel argues that it could not be decided without a view about the purpose of golf. Many of our fights about fairness, he concludes, are really fights about honor and purpose.

Sandel’s own view: we owe more than we choose, so politics cannot be neutral

In the last two chapters Sandel states his own position. Kant and Rawls picture the self as free and independent, bound only by natural duties and by agreements it has made. Sandel adds a third kind of moral tie, obligations of solidarity, which we owe to family, community or nation without having chosen them. He builds on the philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre’s idea that we understand our lives as stories, and that we always find ourselves inside stories that began before us. This is why, for Sandel, a country can owe an apology for wrongs done by earlier generations.

From this he concludes that the state cannot stay neutral between ideas of the good life. Debates about abortion or same-sex marriage, he argues, cannot be settled without taking a view on whether an embryo is a person or on what marriage should honor. His alternative is a “politics of the common good”. It would include civic education and national service, public debate about the moral limits of markets, public money for institutions that rich and poor share, and open argument about moral and religious convictions.

How it differs from other books on justice

Justice is a guided tour with a destination, and that sets it apart from its neighbors. Amartya Sen’s The Idea of Justice, published the same year, argues that we should compare real situations and remove clear injustices instead of designing a perfect society. Sandel spends more time on classic theories and on everyday cases, and much less on poverty and development across the world.

His own later book, What Money Can’t Buy (2012), takes the single chapter on markets and morals and turns it into a whole book, with many more examples of things that money should not buy. If that chapter interests you most, the later book is the better choice. Compared with a university textbook of political philosophy, Justice covers fewer thinkers but gives each one a real test, which makes the theories easier to remember.

Where it falls short

The tour is fair in its details but not in its order. Samuel Moyn, reviewing the book in The Nation, noted that the book is arranged so that the welfare and freedom theories fall before virtue arrives, so the reader reaches Aristotle already prepared to agree. Libertarian readers make a related point: David Gordon argues that Sandel admits most objections to libertarianism fail and still rejects the theory on thin grounds.

Sandel’s own position is also much less developed than the views he criticizes. He says that public life should engage moral and religious convictions, but he gives no method for choosing between rival ideas of the common good. The reviewer John Coleman, writing in America, raised the worry that a politics of strong loyalties could revive the religious and ethnic conflicts that liberal neutrality was meant to calm. Defenders of liberalism, such as Phil Badger in Philosophy Now, add that stories and traditions can also be used for illiberal ends.

Finally, the cases are American and some are dated. The 2008 bank bailouts are fresh news in the book, and the chapter on same-sex marriage was written before the US Supreme Court decided the question in 2015.

Which edition to read

The paperback from Farrar, Straus and Giroux is the edition to buy, because you will want to go back to the Kant and Rawls chapters and follow the notes. The audiobook is read by Sandel himself, unabridged, and works well for the case-based chapters, since the book reads much like his lectures. The Kant chapter is the one place where listening is harder than reading. The free filmed lectures on the course site cover the same ground and make a good companion if you like to see the cases argued out by students.

Quiz

5 questions · up to 5 points

Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.

  1. According to Sandel, which three ideas do arguments about justice keep returning to, as in the debate about high prices after Hurricane Charley?
    Show answer

    Maximizing welfare, respecting freedom and promoting virtue Sandel finds all three in the price-gouging debate: high prices may help supply (welfare), free deals should stand (freedom), and greed in a crisis deserves blame (virtue).

  2. A city compares the cost of a safer road with the money value of the lives it would save, and decides the road is not worth it. Which objection to utilitarianism in the book does this case raise most directly?
    Show answer

    That not all values can be measured on one scale, such as money, without losing something Sandel calls this the problem of a common currency of value. The Ford Pinto and the EPA's lower value for older lives are his examples of the outrage it causes.

  3. Why does Rawls, as Sandel presents him, think that even a fair race with equal schooling for everyone does not produce a just distribution of income?
    Show answer

    Because the fastest runners still win, and natural talent is as much a matter of luck as a rich family This is Rawls's argument from moral arbitrariness. Neither birth into wealth nor natural gifts are your own doing, so neither should decide your share alone.

  4. A club owns one rare violin. Following Aristotle's reasoning about flutes, as Sandel presents it, who should get it?
    Show answer

    The best violinist, because the purpose of a violin is to be played well Aristotle argued that the best flutes should go to the best flute players, because that is what flutes are for. Sandel calls this way of reasoning from purpose teleological.

  5. What is the fairest summary of the book's main weakness, according to this review?
    Show answer

    It explains rival theories well, but its order favors Sandel's own view, which stays vague in practice Critics such as Samuel Moyn noted that welfare and freedom are tested before virtue, and that Sandel gives no clear way to choose between rival ideas of the common good.

The takeaway

Justice by Michael Sandel sorts theories of justice into three families: welfare (utilitarianism), freedom (libertarians, Kant and Rawls) and virtue (Aristotle). He tests each against real cases such as price rises after a hurricane, the Ford Pinto and the trolley, and argues that you cannot decide who deserves what without asking what a good is for. The tour of rival views is clear and fair in detail, but the order of the book favors Sandel's own view, which stays vague. Use it to find the hidden purpose behind your own judgments about fairness.

Key quotes

“But is it possible to translate all moral goods into a single currency of value without losing something in the translation?”
Michael J. Sandel, Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?, chapter 2, p. 41
“Don't handicap the best runners; let them run and do their best.”
Michael J. Sandel, Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?, chapter 6, p. 156
“Freedom of the will is not the kind of thing that science can prove or disprove.”
Michael J. Sandel, Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?, chapter 5, p. 126

Should you read it?

Read it if

  • You want to understand utilitarianism, libertarianism, Kant, Rawls and Aristotle well enough to recognize them in a news debate.
  • You like learning from hard cases, such as the trolley, price rises after a hurricane or paid military service, more than from definitions.
  • You suspect that arguments about markets, merit or marriage hide a question about what things are for, and want words for it.

Skip it if

  • You already know the standard theories of justice and want new philosophical arguments rather than a guided tour.
  • You want a worked-out political program, because Sandel's own proposals stay general.
  • You want a survey that covers traditions beyond Europe and North America, or Marxist and feminist views of justice.

As an Amazon Associate, mentua.org earns from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing and never shapes the verdict.

Ideas from this book

References

  1. Justice with Michael Sandel. Harvard University

    The course site, with the filmed lectures on which the book is based.

  2. This Seeming Brow of Justice. Samuel Moyn, The Nation, 2009

    A review of Justice and Amartya Sen's The Idea of Justice that praises Sandel's survey and argues that its order favors his own view.

  3. Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do? by Michael J. Sandel. David Gordon, Mises Review, 2010

    A libertarian review with page references, arguing that Sandel's case against libertarianism is weaker than it looks.

  4. Communitarianism. Daniel Bell, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2024

    Background on the critics of Rawls, Sandel among them, and why they never adopted the label communitarian themselves.

justice-whats-the-right-thing-to-domichael-sandeljusticepolitical-philosophymoral-philosophyutilitarianismlibertarianismimmanuel-kantjohn-rawlsveil-of-ignorancearistotlecommunitarianismcommon-goodtrolley-problemmarkets-and-moralsharvardbook-reviewsummary

Related reading

More in Philosophy →

What Is the Trolley Problem?

Why most people would pull the lever but not push the man, what the trolley problem really asks, who invented it, and where the thought experiment fails.

5 min read≈ 1,200 words3 questions