What Is the Categorical Imperative?


5 min read≈ 1,190 words3 questions · up to 3 points
What this is about
A lie that solves your problem and is never found out seems to hurt nobody, yet most people still feel it is wrong. You learn the test Immanuel Kant proposed in 1785 to explain why and how it works on a false promise to repay a loan. You also see how a German court used the idea in 2006 and why Kant's strictest conclusion still divides philosophers.
In a nutshell· skip ahead
The categorical imperative is Immanuel Kant's basic test of right and wrong. Before you act, you ask whether the personal rule behind your action could work as a law that everyone follows, and whether you treat other people only as tools. If the rule would defeat itself once everyone followed it, the action is wrong, whatever you want.
Suppose you need 500 euros by Friday, and a friend will lend it to you only if you promise to pay it back next month. You know that you will not be able to, but the lie would solve your problem and nobody else would be harmed. So what exactly would be wrong with it?
How does the categorical imperative work?
The categorical imperative is Immanuel Kant’s test for whether an action is morally allowed: you ask whether you could want the personal rule behind your action to become a law that everyone follows. It is an imperative because it commands, and categorical because it has no “if”. A hypothetical imperative has a condition, as in “if you want to pass the exam, study”, so it binds you only as long as you want the goal. The categorical imperative binds you whatever you want, because Kant thought it comes from reason itself.
Kant stated it in 1785 in the Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals:
Act only on that maxim whereby thou canst at the same time will that it should become a universal law.
A maxim is the personal rule behind an action, your answer if someone asked what you are doing and why. The false promise is Kant’s own example, and the test runs in four steps:
- State the maxim. “When I need money, I will borrow it and promise to pay it back, although I know I never can.”
- Make it a universal law. Picture a world in which everyone who needs money makes false promises.
- Ask whether your maxim could still work in that world. It could not, because nobody would then believe a promise to repay. Your friend would laugh at your promise instead of lending you the money, so the maxim defeats itself as soon as everyone follows it.
- If it passes, ask whether you could want that world. Kant’s example here is the rule “I will never help anyone in need”. A world without help is possible, but you cannot rationally want it, because you will one day need help yourself.
The false promise only works because most promises are honest, so the test catches the liar making an exception for himself that he could not allow to everyone.
Kant gave a second version that he believed says the same thing: treat every person, yourself included, always as an end and never merely as a means. The word “merely” matters: using a baker as a means to get bread is fine, because the baker agrees to the sale. The false promise uses your friend merely as a means, because she could not agree to the deal if she knew the truth.
What the categorical imperative teaches you
The habit to take away is to ask “What if everyone did this?” before you make an exception for yourself, and “Could the other person agree if they knew everything?” before you persuade or use someone.
- Everyday shortcuts. Riding a train without a ticket works only because most passengers pay, and a small lie on a CV works only because most CVs are honest. Both rules would destroy what they rely on if everyone followed them.
- Work and relationships. A colleague flattered into doing your work, or a partner calmed with a kind lie, is used in a way they could not agree to if they knew.
- Shared resources. The logic behind What Is the Tragedy of the Commons? is the same: one extra animal on a shared pasture costs almost nothing, but the rule “I may add one more” ruins the pasture when every herder follows it.
The second version has reached the law. Germany’s Basic Law begins with “Human dignity shall be inviolable”, and the Federal Constitutional Court reads this in a Kantian way, as a ban on treating a person as a mere object. On 15 February 2006 the court struck down a law that would have allowed the air force to shoot down a hijacked passenger plane, because the innocent passengers would have been killed as a means of saving others. The footbridge case in What Is the Trolley Problem? raises the same question, because pushing one man to stop the trolley uses him as a tool.
Where does Kant’s test run into trouble?
Many people think the categorical imperative is a version of the Golden Rule, “treat others as you would like to be treated”. Kant rejected this comparison himself in a footnote of the Groundwork. The Golden Rule depends on what you happen to want, so a criminal could tell the judge that the judge would not like to be punished either, while Kant’s test asks what could work as a law for everyone.
The test has two well-known problems, and the first is that it seems too rigid. In a short essay of 1797, Kant replied to the French writer Benjamin Constant and held that you may not lie even to a murderer who asks where your friend has gone. Most readers, and many Kantians, think this is wrong. The philosopher Christine Korsgaard argued in 1986 that the universal law test itself allows a lie to a murderer who hides his purpose, because a rule of lying to people who deceive you would still work if everyone followed it.
The second problem is that the result depends on how you describe your maxim. “I will make a false promise when I need exactly 500 euros on a Friday” is so narrow that it seems to pass, because a world where everyone follows it would hardly change. A harmless rule such as “I will buy books but never sell them” seems to fail. The German philosopher Hegel concluded that the test is empty and can approve almost anything. Kantians answer that a maxim must state your real reason for acting, and your real reason for the false promise is that you want money you cannot repay, not that it is Friday.
Learn more
The categorical imperative has a clear originator, Immanuel Kant, who lived from 1724 to 1804 and taught in Königsberg in Prussia, now Kaliningrad in Russia, a city he hardly ever left. His idea that freedom means obeying a law you give yourself owes much to Jean-Jacques Rousseau. In the twentieth century John Rawls called his own theory of justice Kantian, and Onora O’Neill and Christine Korsgaard made Kant’s test central to moral philosophy again.
To see Kant next to utilitarianism, Rawls and Aristotle, read “Justice: What’s the Right Thing to Do?” by Michael J. Sandel: Summary and Review, which explains why Kant would not even tell a kind lie to a frail mother. For a test of fairness that grew out of Kant’s ideas, read What Is the Veil of Ignorance?. For Kant’s own words, the Cambridge edition translated by Mary Gregor and Jens Timmermann is a good place to start: Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals (Affiliate Link).
Quiz
3 questions · up to 3 points
Open a question and pick one answer. Only your first answer counts: +1 if it is right, −1 if it is wrong.
Why did Kant call his moral principle a categorical imperative rather than a hypothetical one?
Show answer
Because it commands without any condition, whatever goals or wishes you happen to have A hypothetical imperative says 'if you want X, do Y'. The categorical imperative has no 'if', so it binds every rational being.
Sam rides the train without a ticket and argues that one passenger more or less costs nobody anything. How does the categorical imperative judge Sam's rule?
Show answer
It fails, because riding free only works while most people pay, and if everyone did it there would be no train service to ride Like the false promise, Sam's rule depends on other people not following it. Made into a law for everyone, it defeats its own purpose.
Which statement about the categorical imperative is correct?
Show answer
It does not forbid using people as means, only using them merely as means, without a chance to agree You use a baker to get bread, and that is fine because the baker agrees to the sale. A false promise is wrong because the lender could not agree if they knew the truth.
Your points are saved only in this browser for now. Accounts that keep them for good are on the way.
Continue learning: "Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?" by Michael J. Sandel: Summary and Review →The takeaway
The categorical imperative, Immanuel Kant's principle from 1785, says to act only on a personal rule you could want everyone to follow, and never to treat a person merely as a means. A false promise to repay a loan fails, because if everyone made such promises, nobody would believe one. Critics say the test is too rigid, since Kant forbade lying even to a murderer, and that its result depends on how you describe your rule. Before acting, ask what would happen if everyone did the same, and whether the people affected could agree.
Key quotes
“So act as to treat humanity, whether in thine own person or in that of any other, in every case as an end withal, never as means only.”
References
- Kant's Moral Philosophy. Robert Johnson and Adam Cureton, Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2025
A careful overview of the good will, hypothetical and categorical imperatives, the four steps of the universal law test and the formula of humanity.
- Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. Immanuel Kant, translated by Thomas Kingsmill Abbott, Wikisource, 1785
The full text in a free English translation. The false promise and Kant's three other examples are in the second section.
- Bidding Farewell to Kant's Murderer at the Door. Jens Timmermann, Cambridge University Press, Fifteen Eighty Four, 2025
A short piece by a Kant scholar on what Kant really said about lying to a murderer in 1797, and why neither he nor Constant mentioned a door.
- Judgment of 15 February 2006, 1 BvR 357/05 (press release). Federal Constitutional Court of Germany, Bundesverfassungsgericht, 2006
The court's English summary of why the state may not shoot down a hijacked plane with innocent passengers on board.





